Monday, 26 January 2015

Greece is the Word..



The election campaign has settled into a familiar if somewhat enervating routine. Major intervention on Monday, argument over the figures on Tuesday, hurry back to Westminster to pretend to be working Wednesday, out to the constituencies to prepare for government/look for jobs in the private sector on Thursdays and Fridays. Rinse, repeat. (It's the PM's turn this week, who will say later that Britain is experiencing a "tax moment" before pledging greater tax cuts and attacking the "enemies of aspiration" aka Nick Clegg and Ed Miliband.) 

But it's an election elsewhere in Europe that takes the headlines today. "Greek drama engulfs the Euro" is our splash. "Syriza's historic win puts Greece on collision course with Europe" is the Guardian's take. "Greek leftists' victory throws down challenge to Euro establishment" is the FT's tongue-twister. "Europe rocked by Greek revolt against austerity" says the Times' frontpage while the Indy goes for "Greece and EU on collision course after election win for left". 

Alexis Tsipras' far-left party is projected to fall just two seats short of an absolute majority but will finish miles ahead of the governing centre-right party New Democracy. It appears that Syriza will form a coalition with the right-wing ANEL, suggesting that the incoming government is unlikely to "blink first" in negotiations with its Eurozone creditors. 

If there is a further crisis within the Eurozone, what will the consequences be for the election here? It may be that it encourages the electorate to rally round to the government. (Fact of the day via the excellent Sex, Lies and the Ballot Box: voters who described themselves as "scared" by the financial crisis were more likely to stick with Gordon Brown, while those calling themselves "angry" went with the Opposition.)

What will certainly happen, even if Mr Tsipiras goes the way of Francois Hollande, is an emboldened left flank within the Labour party. You can see the outlines of the argument: Labour in is retreat thanks to a party of the left - the SNP - in Scotland and its vote is being eroded by another party of the far-left - the Greens - in England. While there is a great deal to criticize around Ed Miliband's operation they have, for the most part, been pretty good at keeping the party's left quiet if not happy. (See the row-that-wasn't over the party's harder line on borrowing, for instance.) It seems likely that that silence will endure until after the election. But whether Ed Miliband is in retirement or in Downing Street without a majority after that, you can expect to hear a lot more about Mr Tsipiras' big win from Labour politicians, regardless of what happens next in Greece. 



IT'S MY TAX CUT!

Danny Alexander will seek to steal David Cameron's clothes with an announcement that more than eight million households will be £1330 better off thanks to the threshold raise, Francis Elliot reports in the Times. Mr Alexander has reminded people that the Conservatives dismissed the threshold raise during the leadership debates and that he and Nick Clegg have "fought tooth and nail" to secure rises in the allowance. It may take some of the limelight from the PM's taxation pledges. "We are the low-tax, tax-cutting party," Mr Cameron will say. 

LEARNT MY LESSON WELL

Peter Mandelson tells Patrick Wintour that Labour must avoid repeating the mistake of 2010, when the party was poorly prepared for coalition negotiations. "It was all too makeshift," Lord Mandelson says of Labour's approach last time, which the then Business Secretary led, "If we had bene serious the talking should have started long before." 

THINGS GET FRACKTIOUS

The Government faces a tricky vote on the Infrastructure Bill today, as both Conservative and Liberal MPs are prepared to rebel, with a number of MPs tabling an amendment calling for a moratorium on fracking. Labour support will now be vital to get the Bill out of the committee stage, with the Opposition tabling their own amendment calling for tighter environmental regulations stopping short of a moratorium.The Government may end up being grateful to Len McCluskey; his Unite union, along with the GMB, have written to Labour MPs urging them not to close the door on fracking. Francis Elliot has the story in the Times. 

BASHING BASHIR

Nigel Farage has reacted angrily to Amjad Bashir MEP's defection to the Conservative Party. "He's not dumping me, I'm dumping him," he told Andrew Marr. (I paraphrase.) Mr Farage says that Ukip had become "increasingly alarmed" about allegations around Mr Bashir. Mr Bashir insists there is "not a shred of truth" to the allegations, and says its a "desperate attempt" to distract from the news of his defection.

RED, RED LINES

Jim Murphy has added his voice to those urging Labour to make Trident a red line in coalition negotiations. The decision about the deterrent should not be about "Playing footsie about possible coalitions with other parties," Mr Murphy told the Sunday Politics, "It's about negotiations with other nuclear states to ensure the world is nuclear free." Simon Johnson has the story. 

THE SPY WHO RUNG ME

A hoax caller pretended to be the GCHQ director Robert Hannigan and was succesfully put through to the PM, before ringing the Sun to brag about it. "I've just made complete monkeys out of GCHQ," he said, "What's more, I am off my fac eon booze and cocaine. I have some spliffs too." "Con Her Majesty's Secret Service" is their splash.

You can get in touch with me by pressing "reply" or on Twitter. Our cartoon is the work of Christian Adams- a gallery of his work is available here.


HOW HAVE THE POLLS MOVED IN THE PAST MONTH?


Poll-of-Polls (Ashcroft-Populus-ICM-Ipsos-YouGov) Conservatives 32% Labour 33% Liberal Democrat 8% Ukip 15% Greens 8% 

LATEST POLLS:

Populus: Conservatives 32% Labour 36% Liberal Democrat 9% Ukip 13% Green 6%

YouGov: Conservatives 32% Labour 33% Liberal Democrat 7% Ukip 15% Green 7%

TOO MANY TWEETS...

@labourpaul: The most important lesson for UK politicians from the Greek elections is that there isn't one.

COMMENT

From the Telegraph

Boris Johnson - The Kurds' cause is ours - let's help them fight the barbarians

Peter Oborne - Nothing will be solved by Syriza's empty promises

From elsewhere

Matthew D'Ancona - Ukip now resembles its enemies, just like Animal Farm's pigs (Guardian)

George Magnus - Who will blink now Syriza has won? (FT)

AGENDA

1030 LONDON: Boris Johnson joins Assembly to host Holocaust Memorial Day ceremony. 

1100 YORK: The Rev Libby Lane to be consecrated as the first female Church of England bishop. 

1230 LONDON: Vivienne Westwood and Bianca Jagger join protest and petition handover against fracking in Parliament Square.

TODAY IN PARLIAMENT

COMMONS: 1430 

Work and Pensions Questions. 

Infrastructure Bill [HL] - Report stage and third reading. 

A short debate on UK support for Pakistan after the massacre in Peshawar. 

LORDS: 1430 

Questions. 

Counter-Terrorism and Security Bill - Committee of the whole House (Day 2). 

A short debate on the future of museums in regional areas.

Friday, 23 January 2015

No one puts Paisley in the corner..



Debate invitations are like buses - you wait for ages and then two come at once. The broadcasters have struck up a new deal to get David Cameron on board, and the Greens' Natalie Bennett will be involved after all. 

It's almost exactly what the PM asked for: two seven-way debates between the Conservatives, Labour, the Liberal Democrats, Ukip, the Greens, the SNP and Plaid Cymru and one between the two men who could be Prime Minister. The plans look "designed to call Cameron's bluff" is Nick Robinson's verdict. 

But they may have been too clever by half. The DUP, who have eight MPs, are wondering exactly why the SNP with six MPs, are invited, the Plaids, with three, are invited, but neither their overall leader, Peter Robinson, or their Westminster chief, Nigel Dodds, are in. (Mr Robinson has written to the broadcasters demanding an explanation) The Liberal Democrats, meanwhile, aren't exactly thrilled to be relegated to second-tier. "Televised election debate plans in disarray" is our splash. 

Frankly no-one can say with any confidence how a seven-way debate will play out or even if it will happen at all. It feels increasingly unlikely that either David Cameron or Ed Miliband will be able to avoid a debate of one kind or another, although the format preferred by our digital debate, comprising the five national parties, may win out in the end. But if the 7-7-2 format does make it to our screens, my instinct is that the mass debates will be watched only by an eccentric few. (Tune in see at least one person you can't vote for debate at least one person you can't stand: LIVE!) That puts the focus on the one-on-one between the PM and the Labour leader. 

What happens there is anyone's guess. It certainly puts the focus where the Conservatives want it: on the contrast between Mr Cameron and Mr Miliband. Who benefits then depends on which Ed Miliband turns up. As Mr Miliband proved at last week's Fabian Society conference when he turns it on he can deliver a polished performance. If that Miliband turns up then the debates should go well for the Opposition. What happens if the other Miliband, who couldn't explain the difference between taxing a £2 million house and a glass of water, turns up instead?



Q€

European Central Bank president Mario Draghi has announced a €1.1 trillion programme of quantitative easing to stimulate the flagging Eurozone and to stave off deflation. The pound soared to a six-year high against the Euro after the ECB's announcement. While it will make British exports more expensive it's good news for imports and British holidaymakers. "Bonanza for Britain as cash floods into Europe" is the Times' splash. Bruno Waterfield and Peter Spence have the story. 

INTEGRATE HEALTH AND SOCIAL CARE OR DIE TRYIN'  

Labour's highly-rated health and social care spokesman Liz Kendall speaks to Paul Waugh and Daniel Bond in the House Magazine. Among the revelations: she mostly listens to rap, with Dr Dre, mid-Noughties Jay Z and Public Enemy her favourites. But it's her comments on NHS privitisation that have caught the eye of James Chapman in the Mail: "what matters is what works", Ms Kendall says, in an implicit rebuke to Andy Burnham. 

DAN, DAN, HE'S OUR MAN

It's another one of Labour's new generation that has caught James Kirkup's eye. Dan Jarvis ends his tour of marginal seats today with campaign stops in Elmet & Rothwell, Pudsey and Great Grimsby. "In politics, as in sport, it's rarely a bad idea to do the thing your opponent least wants you to do," James muses, "How do you think the Conservatives would feel about a Jarvis-led Labour Party?" 

SNP-TORY CO-OPERATION IS LIKE, SOOOOO 2007

Nicola Sturgeon says that the further powers for Scotland don't go far enough and that David Cameron has broken his promise to the Scottish people in an article for the Guardian. She reiterated her opposition to supporting a Tory government in Westminster. But Fraser Nelson's not convinced. "Without a villian, Ms Sturgeon will not have much of a pantomime; so she needs Cameron". If the SNP are kingmakers, they will "likely set sky-high demands and then walk out of coalition talks". 

LEON BRITTAN

Lord Brittan, who as Leon Brittan was Home Secretary and Trade and Industry Secretary under Margaret Thatcher, has died. His last years were marked by allegations that he was involved in a cover-up of child sexual abuse in the 1980s. "Now Will We Ever Find Truth On Abuse Dossier?" is the Mail's splash. 

YOU CAN'T TRUST PEOPLE

The New Labour years recieve the Peep Show treatement courtesy of Jon Laurence and his team. Have a lovely weekend. 

You can get in touch with me by pressing "reply" or on Twitter. Our cartoon is the work of Christian Adams- a gallery of his work is available here.


HOW HAVE THE POLLS MOVED IN THE PAST MONTH?


Poll-of-Polls (Ashcroft-ComRes-Populus-Opinium-ICM-Ipsos-YouGov) Conservatives 32% Labour 33% Liberal Democrat 8% Ukip 15% Greens 7% 

LATEST POLLS:

YouGov: Conservatives 31% Labour 33% Liberal Democrat 7% Ukip 17% Green 8%

TOO MANY TWEETS...

@hopisen: Having worked around parliament for several years, can say we need a campaign for clear demonstration enunciation. What do you want again?

COMMENT

From the Telegraph

James Kirkup - Meet the man who should lead Labour after Ed Miliband

Fraser Nelson - What the SNP really wants is Mr Cameron back in No 10

From elsewhere

Philip Collins - The mansion tax is typical of blinkered Labour (Times)

Gaby Hinsliff - The Sun's Page 3 cynicism isn't just about lust. It's about resentment and power (Guardian)

AGENDA

0930 LONDON: Retail sales figures for December are published by the Office for National Statistics. 

TODAY IN PARLIAMENT

COMMONS - 0930: 

HS2 Funding Referendum Bill - Second reading. 

Overseas Voters Bill - Second reading. 

Working Time Directive (Limitation) Bill - Second reading. 

Political Party Policy Costings (Office for Budget Responsibility) Bill - Second reading. 

Housing (Affordability, Supply and Tenant Protection) Bill - Second reading. 

Under-occupancy Penalty (Exemptions) Bill - Second reading. 

Protective Headgear for Cyclists Aged Fourteen Years and Under (Research) Bill - Second reading. 

Zero-Hours Contracts Bill - Second reading (Day 2). 

Parliamentary and Constitutional Reform Bill - Second reading. 

Tenancies (Reform) Bill - Second reading (Day 2) . 

United Kingdom Parliament (Sovereignty and Jurisdiction over Borders) Bill - Second reading. 

Household Safety (Carbon Monoxide Detectors) Bill - Second reading (Day 2). 

Funeral Services Bill - Second reading. 

Off-Road Vehicles (Registration) Bill - Second reading. 

Women's Refuges (Provision and Eligibility) Bill - Second reading. 

House of Lords (Expulsion and Suspension) Bill (HL) - Second reading. 

A short debate on Coventry's economy and City Link. 

LORDS - 1000 

Specialist Printing Equipment and Materials (Offences) Bill - Second reading. 

International Development (Official Development Assistance Target) Bill - Second reading. 

Medical Innovation Bill (HL) - Third reading.

Thursday, 22 January 2015

Time is running out..


The PM makes his first post-referendum visit to Scotland today to mark the publication of the draft clauses relating to further powers for Scotland - further control over tax, spending and welfare will pass to Holyrood, while legislation will be passed to confirm the Scottish parliament as a permanent institution.  "The new United Kingdom" is the i's frontpage. 

It's the party that will be using those powers at Holyrood that takes the headlines elsewhere. Nicola Sturgeon has reversed the SNP's self-denying ordinance on "English only issues" at Westminster, raising the prospect of a Labour-SNP coalition or a confidence and supply arrangement.  "SNP plan to vote on English laws" is the splash to our Scottish edition, "SNP to vote on English laws" is the Times' take. 

In reality, the impact of the Barnett formula means that, even with significant devolution of Scottish revenue-raising to Holyrood, there are very few issues that can genuinely be described as "English only". But Ms Sturgeon's words are largely about defusing the Labour line of "vote SNP, get Tory". 

The latest IpsosMori suggests that the line may not be as potent as Labour hope in any case. The Nationalists are way ahead on 52% to 24%, with none of the minor movement picked up in the recent Panelbase and Survation polls. It's very probably an outlier, but it's a reminder of the scale of Labour's challenge north of the border. It's also worth noting that beneath the headlines, Labour still leads in Scotland as the party that people are "most inclined to vote for" (25% to the SNP's 10% in 2012, 20% to 14% now) suggesting that any talk of a permanent SNP majority is misplaced. 

But for all the arrival of Jim Murphy - "the best we've had since Donald Dewar" in the words of one Labour MP - has given the party a greater spring in its step the political, policy, not to mention organisational challenges to Scottish Labour will take time for reverse. The trouble for Labour is that time is running out. 



LORD FARAGE?

Tom Newton Dunn has got hold of a tape of Ukip's immigration spokesman, Steven Woolfe, badmouthing Nigel Farage and speculating that the Ukip leader might do a deal with the Conservatives in exchange for a peerage. Mr Woolfe says that he "naively believed" the rumours at the time but now thinks they are "complete and utter drivel". But the tape emerges as rumours abound around Tim Aker's defenestration as policy chief and of friction between Douglas Carswell and his leader. "Ukip don't seem quite the breath of fresh air some thought," the Sun chuckles in its leader. 

OAKESHOTT 

Beth Rigby reveals in the FT that defenestrated Vince Cable ally and ex-Liberal Democrat peer Matthew Oakeshott is giving hundreds of thousands of pounds to 30 Labour candidates in order to boost Ed Miliband's chances of becoming PM and scotch any possibility of an In-Out referendum. Lord Oakeshott, an ex-SDPer, has donated £600,000 across 46 marginal seats with £300,000 going to Labour candidates and the remainder going to Liberal Democrats and Caroline Lucas in Brighton Pavillion. (George Eaton has a complete list.) 

DEBATES ABOUT DEBATES

Broadcasters are set to put a new proposal to the party leaders that would include Nicola Sturgeon and Natalie Bennet, John Plunkett and Tara Conlan report in the Guardian.  

SMOKE GETS IN YOUR EYES

There will be a pre-election vote to introduce plain packaging of cigarettes across the country, Peter Dominiczak reports. Strong cross-party support means it ishighly likely to pass the House, but the TPA's Jonathan Isaby isn't happy. It's "another victory for the nanny state" and is "likely to encourage counterfeiters to flood the black market and hit Treasury revenues".  

HARMAN VS NEANDERTHALS

Ukip is a party led by "Neanderthal sexists", Harriet Harman says. Nigel Farage himself has admitted that the party can come off as a tad "blokeish". But, he asked, "What do you want me to do? Go sell flowers?" James Chapman has the story in the Mail. 

 

You can get in touch with me by pressing "reply" or on Twitter. Our cartoon is the work of Christian Adams- a gallery of his work is available here.


HOW HAVE THE POLLS MOVED IN THE PAST MONTH?


Poll-of-Polls (Ashcroft-Populus-Opinium-ICM-Ipsos-YouGov) Conservatives 32% Labour 33% Liberal Democrat 8% Ukip 15% Greens 7% 

LATEST POLLS:

YouGov: Conservatives 33% Labour 34% Liberal Democrat 6% Ukip 14% Green 8%

TOO MANY TWEETS...

@alexmassie: As was the case with Marilyn Monroe, it is exceptionally difficult to take a boring photograph of Ed Miliband. 

COMMENT

From the Telegraph

James Kirkup - Never mind Iraq. The real scandal is Britain's forgotten war in Afghanistan

From elsewhere

George Eaton - Labour and Tories aren't the same - so why do voters still think they are? (NS)

AGENDA

0900: Nick Clegg on LBC radio.

0930 LONDON: Philip Hammond hosts a meeting of the Global Coalition to Counter ISIL.

1000 EDINBURGH: Government to publish draft clauses to deliver more powers to Scotland. Scottish Secretary Alistair Carmichael and Chief Secretary to the Treasury Danny Alexander will attend.

1130 BELFAST: Labour leader Ed Miliband in Belfast. 

1200 LONDON: Prime Minister's Questions. 

1700: Ed Balls on LBC radio.

1930 BELFAST: Ed Miliband to address a local business community in Belfast.

TODAY IN PARLIAMENT

PARLIAMENT 

COMMONS - 0930: 

Transport Questions. 

Leader of the House and House of Commons Commission Questions. 

A statement on the future business of the House. 

A statement on the publication of draft Scotland clauses. 

A debate on a motion relating to the governance of the House of Commons. 

A short debate on the fire risk in timber-framed houses. 

Westminster Hall: 

1330: i) A debate on the third report from the Energy And Climate Change Committee: The Green Deal and ii) A debate on the first report from the Justice Committee session: Crime Reduction Policies. 

LORDS - 1000: 

Questions. 

A debate on improving investment in and planning for the UK's national infrastructure. 

A short debate on improving access to the criminal justice system and victim support for people with autism spectrum disorders. 

A debate on Local Government Finance Settlement and its implications for the future of local government.

Wednesday, 21 January 2015

Telegraph Morning Briefing


Green Grass & High Tides.. 

Good morning. Natalie Bennett will be feeling awfully chipper this morning. ICM has the Greens at their highest rating with that pollster for 20 years (9%). The latest Ashcroft has her party on 11%. And today's YouGov poll for the Sun has the party at its highest ever rating for that pollster (10%). That's contributed to Labour's worst rating with YouGov for five years - they're down to 30%. "Ed's Triple Whammy" is the Sun's headline. 

The usual caveats about getting too excited about individual polls apply. Added to that, remember that poll fluctuations can be caused by bursts of enthusiasm - or the lack thereof - among the supporters of one party or another. (If you are a depressed Labour supporter you're less likely to take the time to participate in a poll than a newly-enrolled Green) But given the surge in their membership and the increased focus on the Greens due to the ongoing row over the debates, it seems likely that Ms Bennett's party will continue to rise in the polls. Yes, there will be increased scrutiny of their members and their manifesto, but as Ukip has shown, the usual rules don't quite apply to populist parties.

Champagne all round in CCHQ and Downing Street? The decision to focus on the Greens' exclusion on the debates, to raise their profile to the discomfort of Ed Miliband looks as if it's being validated. It's a "Ukip of the left" is the familiar refrain. But I'm not so sure. It feels not so very long ago that Labour figures were telling all and sundry that they had nothing to fear from Nigel Farage, or that the only party with reason to fear the SNP at Westminster was the Conservatives. The Greens are feeding off the same disillusionment with politics that keeps Ukip in the game. And frankly, if you look at the profile of the Green defectors - young, well-educated, disillusioned by Ed Miliband and more inclined to trust the PM and his Chancellor over the Eds on the economy - the question has to be asked: shouldn't at least some of these people be being targeted by the Conservatives? 



STRIKES

Jeremy Hunt has warned paramedics that their 12-hour strike will put patients at risk, Peter Dominiczak and Laura Donnelly report. The unions are demanding a 1% pay rise. "Paramedics told: your strike over pay could kill patients" is our splash. 

SHOULD HAVE ASKED TIM AKER TO WRITE IT

The Chilcot inquiry will be delayed until after the next election. "Outrage as Chilcot report is delayed until after the election" is the Indy's splash.  "Verdict delayed - no Iraq war report until after the election" is the Guardian's take. It's the Maxwellisation process of consulting those criticising that is taking so much time.  Bernard Jenkin is unfazed: the inquiry into Bloody Sunday "took a decade when it was never meant to do so", Mr Jenkin pointed out on Today.

THERESA VS TEHRAN

The Foreign Office has accused Theresa May of jeopardising plans to re-open the British embassy in Iran because of her tough line on immigration, Laura Pitel and Hugh Tomlinson report in the Times. Mrs May is said to be refusing to open a visa office - a "key demand" by Tehran - until 4,000 Iranians who do not have leave to remain in Britain are deported. "'Hardline' May accused of blocking Tehran deal" is the Thunderer's splash. 

FREELOADERS?

Britain is "wide open to abuse" from "freeloading" European migrants says Philip Hammond. "Free movement to work is one of the principles of the European Union, free movmeent to freeload is not." Raziye Akkoc has the figures on benefit claimants. 

VISIT FRANCE: GET A FOCUS GROUP THROWN IN FREE!

A good anecdote from Jim Murphy via the Times Diary. A recent camping holiday brought an awkward encounter with a fellow camper. "You look just like that Jim Murphy," they said. "Oh, ah," replied Mr Murphy. "You also sound like him." Just a coincidence, Mr Murphy, who was eager to have a quiet holiday, said. "Good," came the reply, "I wouldn't want to spend ten days pitched next to that prick."

You can get in touch with me by pressing "reply" or on Twitter. Our cartoon is the work of Christian Adams- a gallery of his work is available here.


HOW HAVE THE POLLS MOVED IN THE PAST MONTH?


Poll-of-Polls (Ashcroft-Populus-Opinium-ICM-Ipsos-YouGov) Conservatives 32% Labour 33% Liberal Democrat 8% Ukip 15% Greens 7% 

LATEST POLLS:

ICM: Conservatives 30% Labour 33% Liberal Democrat 11% Ukip 11% Green 9%

YouGov: Conservatives 32% Labour 30% Liberal Democrat 8% Ukip 15% Green 10%

TOO MANY TWEETS...

@ChairmanMoet: That Tim Aker story instantly transported me back, in an anxious reverie, to all the work deadlines I've spectacularly failed to meet. Awful

COMMENT

From the Telegraph

Mary Riddell - Ed Miliband needs to get his groove back to fight off the Greens

James Kirkup - George Osborne's tainted love for Boris Johnson

From elsewhere

Daniel Finkelstein - Here's why we all have reason to be fearful (Times)

Rafael Behr - The general election could unleash a new wave of contempt for politics (Guardian)

AGENDA

1000 LONDON: Energy Secretary Ed Davey gives evidence to the Commons Energy and Climate Change Committee.

1200 LONDON: Prime Minister's Questions. 

1700: Ed Balls on LBC radio.

1930 BELFAST: Ed Miliband to address a local business community in Belfast.

TODAY IN PARLIAMENT

COMMONS - 1130: 

Wales Questions. 

Prime Minister's Questions. 

A 10 Minute Rule Motion: Onshore Wind Turbine Subsidies (Abolition). 

An Opposition Day debate: The NHS. 

A motion to approve a statutory instrument relating to terrorism. 

A short debate on the implementation of the introduction of standardised packaging of tobacco products. 

Westminster Hall: 

0930: Implications of the independent review of Personal Independence Payments. 

1100: Fuel prices in the UK. 

1430: Government support for homeless young people. 

1600: Mobile phone coverage in East Yorkshire and North Linconshire. 

1630: Future of adult social care. 

LORDS - 1500: 

Questions. 

National Insurance Contributions Bill - Third reading. 

Criminal Justice and Courts Bill - Consideration of Commons amendments. 

A debate on the report of the Communications Committee on Broadcast general election debates.

Monday, 19 January 2015

Shooting Labour's fox..


Has Ed Miliband's fox been shot? Boris Johnson certainly seems to think so. "I remember a time when it was absolutely clear how Labour was going to fight the election," the Mayor of London writes in his column today. " They had a flagship policy, an idea that resonated across the country," Mr Johnson says of the energy price freeze - now the energy price cap - but now? "The flagship is holed below the waterline." Falling energy prices, the rise of discount supermarkets and the possibility of so-called "joyflation" all easing the pressure on wages has undermined the Opposition's "cost of living" offensive - or, at least, that's our leader's verdict. 

David Cameron will seek to keep up the pressure with a commitment to full employment and to make Britain the "jobs factory of Europe" in a speech later today, while George Osborne's celebration of falling fuel prices is today's Times' splash. ("Plunging fuel prices give boost to family spending" is their take.) The PM will hope to add to Labour's discomfort with further raids on their territory, saying that the Conseratives are the party of "retailers and roofers". But the economic picture isn't quite as rosy as the Government might hope. The Centre for Cities think tank finds that the last decade has seen growth concentrated in London and the South while the North stagnates.  "North-South divide gets a lot worse" wails the i's frontpage. "Divided UK: for every 12 jobs created in the South, one is lost in the North" is the Indy's splash. Elsewhere, John Bingham reports on a "drastic" deterioation in the living standards of single-earner households, who are no longer pulling in enough money to keep up a decent standard of living. 

Ed Miliband himself, however, is still in fine form. Privately, he still believes that Labour can take around 36-38% of the vote in May, while his team believe that the PM has erred by moving onto the territory of wage rises and living standards - they believe that he's conceded the argument. Others in Labour fear a re-run of the 1980s: stagnation and recession in the North, but enough growth - or the hope of it - in the right parts of the country to re-elect the Conservatives. But it may be that this time it's different. Our John Bingham reports on the decline in the purchasing power of single-earner households over the last five years. The governments of Margaret Thatcher presided over higher unemployment, but stronger wage growth too. It may be that the PM recieves a less fulsome reward at the ballot box for high employment and sluggish wage levels. 


CLEGG AND MILIBAND UNITE ON MENTAL HEALTH

Ed Miliband has committed a Labour government to reversing the cuts to children's mental health services as part of a greater focus on mental health. Labour believe that "smart investments" in child mental health can reduce the overall mental health spend - a third of all adult mental health cases begin in childhood but the area has just 6% of the overall health budget. Elsewhere, Nick Clegg will todaypledge to roll out a "zero suicides" target that has reduced suicides in target areas nationwide. 

NEXT YEAR, IN JERUSALEM...

The government will increase its efforts to tackle anti-Semitism, Theresa May has announced. It comes as a survey for the Jewish Chronicle found that 43% of Jewish people felt that life in Britain was getting worse and one in 10 have considered leaving the country altogether. Matt Holehouse has the story. 

BLOCK-AIDE

Alistair Thompson, a right-wing campaigner with close links to Owen Paterson, has been removed from the Conservatives' approved candidates list, ostensibly due to his failure to campaign in Newark. But Mr Thompson says that friends in CCHQ have told him that his links to Mr Paterson are the real reason for his purge. Sam Coates has the story in the Times. 

LETTERS FROM ERIC

The Government has written to every mosque in the country to tell Muslim faith leaders that they must do more to root out the "men of hate" who spread extremism, Matt Holehouse reveals. Whitehall is unable to defeat extremism alone and Muslim leaders have a "responsibility" to tackle the problem, the letter says. "Mosques ordered to root out extremists" is our splash.

FEES 

Labour's plans for a tuition fee reduction are foundering due to an inability to find the cash to fund the reduction from a £9,000 fee to £6,000, Sam Coates writes in the Times. The Opposition planned to annouce a £3,000 reduction upfront and a process to gradually move to a full-blooded graduate tax, but costs may mean that the current policy survives a change of government. 

BRIGHT BLUE

A Survation poll for the Conservative modernisers, Bright Blue, finds that less than one in six Conservatives believe than an ideal immigration system would reduce the overall number of immigrants, against one in four Ukip supporters. Bright Blue's director, Ryan Shorthouse, says that the findings show that there is little value in trying to "out-Ukip Ukip". Chris Hope has the story.. 



You can get in touch with me by pressing "reply" or on Twitter.  Our cartoon is the work of Christian Adams- a gallery of his work is available here. 

 

HOW HAVE THE POLLS MOVED IN THE PAST MONTH?

19.01.15

Conservatives 32% Labour 33% Liberal Democrat 7% Ukip 15% Greens 6%


LATEST POLLS:

ComRes:Conservatives 33% Labour 34%  Liberal Democrat 7% Ukip 18% Green 3%

Opinium: Conservatives 28% Labour 33% Liberal Democrat 7% Ukip 20% Green 6%

Populus: Conservatives 32% Labour 35% Liberal Democrat 9% Ukip 14% Green 6%

YouGov:  Conservatives 31% Labour 32% Liberal Democrat 7% Ukip 18% Green 7%

TOO MANY TWEETS...

@mattholehouse: According to FCO guidance, Saudi prison conditions are "quite good" with air con cells. However, they may stone you or cut your hands off.

COMMENT

From the Telegraph

Iain Martin - What's the point of Davos? The Enlightenment must be defended - or we'll be sorry

Boris Johnson - Labour's energy freeze is dead and Ed has nothing else to offer

From elsewhere

Matthew D'Ancona - Rumours of Cameron's demise are greatly exaggerated (Guardian) 

AGENDA

1000 LONDON: Nick Clegg speech at mental health conference.

1015 EAST OF ENGLAND: David Cameron speech. 

1500 LONDON: Prime minister of New Zealand and culture secretary launching Gallipoli commemorations. Culture Secretary Sajid Javid and PM John Key are meeting to ask descendants of those who fought in the 1915 Gallipoli campaign to come forward and play a role in the commemorations on 25 April Anzac Day at the Cenotaph to mark the 100th anniversary. 

1800 LONDON: David Laws speech to Institute for Government on "effective government in 2015 and beyond".

TODAY IN PARLIAMENT

Commons: 1430 

Education Questions. 

Lords Spiritual (Women) Bill - all stages. 

A short debate on the future of Millhouse Green Post Office.

Lords: 1430 

Questions. 

Recall of MPs Bill - Committee of the whole House (Day 2) 

A short debate on support given to individual artists, including visual artists, writers and composers.

Sunday, 18 January 2015

Letter from Tim..


MONTGOMERIE Tim offical

Dear Grant,

I really enjoyed your interview in yesterday's Times (£)and hope you'll soon get your Nando's Black Card! I can't believe that David Beckham deserves one more than you.

I'm glad to hear that Conservative MPs are likely to get a vote on any coalition deal that might be necessary after the next election. That's at least how I read your answer to the question posed by my Times colleagues Rachel Sylvester and Alice Thomson. May I encourage the party to go further and also give all paid-up members a vote? Because a) they deserve one, and b) they can be trusted with one…

  • Over the next few months tens of thousands of party members will give an enormous amount of time to the party's candidates and ground war. They'll give up weekends. They'll go out on evenings after busy days at work to deliver leaflets and knock on doors. Some will use their annual holiday entitlements for campaigning. Other less mobile members will also be doing their bit. Stuffing envelopes. Processing questionnaires. Staffing call centres. Many members will write large cheques to local associations. They'll do all of this without hope or expectation of any personal gain. They'll be doing it all because they love their country and want her to have a Conservative prime minister and cabinet.
  • Some people in the press – and a few too many near the top of the Conservative Party who should know better – would hate the idea of the Tory grassroots having any say in the future government of the country. We know that the caricature of party members is grossly unfair. Rather than being backwards in their social attitudes the bluest of blue Tory Associations keep choosing women candidates, gay candidates and candidates from ethnic backgrounds. ON MERIT! If you look at the ratio of "diversity" candidates actually selected versus the percentage of "diversity" candidates who actually apply to be on the PPC list the party is taking giant strides forward and all without the unmeritocratic measures deployed by Labour. The political views of party members are also much more mainstream than most outsiders might believe. A large majority of Tory members reject a pact with UKIP in the regular ConHome surveys. They are not obsessed with tax cuts but put faster deficit reduction before, for example, a cut in the 40p tax band. More members think students should be excluded from the immigration target than included.

Paul Goodman and Peter Hoskin have already recommended giving party members a vote on any coalition deal. It seems a proper way of recognising their contribution to the party – and it would go much beyond the traditional warm but not necessarily meaningful words of "thank you" that are uttered in their direction.

There is another reason why I hope you and David Cameron will think about this extension of party democracy. One of the reasons that Nick Clegg has not suffered defections or other big wobbles during this parliament was that he consulted his whole party on the Coalition Agreement. He explained what he was doing and then they endorsed his deal with Mr Cameron. Democratically. Because of that "buy in" they've held together much more happily than if there never had been a consultation. David Cameron could enjoy a happier second term if his programme for government is similarly endorsed. Given the party membership's record of loyalty to previous leaders I would even predict that the grassroots are more likely to endorse any deal proposed by the prime minister than the parliamentary party.

I'd be grateful for your thoughts,

With best wishes, Tim

PS I'm also fed up of being told by Liberal Democrats that their party is more democratic than ours

From The Red Box..


Remember how Labour goes on about the NHS, trying to "weaponise" the issue for voters and the Tories want to make our eyes bleed by hammering away at the economy? Well today is a day of new hope, a moment of release, in which we celebrate the great variety of British politics. Because the Tories are going on about the NHS and Labour is banging on about the economy.

While he may deplore the phrase, Jeremy Hunt is today giving a good impression of someone keen to "weaponise" the NHS in Wales. The health secretary has seized on two interventions this morning in The Sunday Times designed to make life awkward for Ed Miliband. A group of 105 patients who have suffered at the hands of the less than stellar Welsh NHS has written to the Labour leader to complain that he is complaining about a crisis in England, whilst remaining mute about the problems on his party's watch in Wales. They want a public inquiry into the performance of Welsh health along the lines of the Francis inquiry into the scandal at Mid Staffs hospital. They are backed up by Sir Norman Williams, a former president of the Royal College of Surgeons, who said: "A reluctance to acknowledge clinical concerns resulted in serious harm in Mid Staffs NHS Trust, so it is perhaps time . . . to accept there are significant problems and mount an investigation akin to the Francis Inquiry into Mid Staffs."

I'm told David Cameron is likely to make hay with all this later this week. He and Hunt will cite figures from a report by the House of Commons library, which points out that on pretty well every metric like A&E waiting times, ambulance times and cancer waits, Wales performs worse than England.

With the Tories campaigning on Labour's favoured turf, Miliband yesterday made a speech on the economy, seen as Cameron's strong suit. Seizing on comments made by the prime minister that he wants to see wages rise, Miliband said it was an admission of failure by Cameron that he has failed to raise living standards. Voters, Miliband suggested, would be "choking on their cornflakes".

"Suddenly he wants to say, after five years of denial, after five years of saying everything is fixed, suddenly he is now the guy who wants wages to go up," Miliband said. "It is frankly totally implausible and ridiculous." Miliband central are convinced that Cameron has made a major strategic error by conceding that living standards – a Labour strong suit – have declined. Tories would point out that George Osborne called long ago for a minimum wage of £8 and Boris Johnson is just as vociferous an advocate of a living wage as Labour are.

But that was all yesterday. The health-wealth role reversal has this morning, reverted to type. Labour are back on the NHS, issuing a report which claims that the government's failure to tackle mental health issues is costing the health service more than £3bn a year and has contributed to the overloading of A&E departments.

The people most likely to be choking on their cornflakes are Miliband's team, who are digesting the splash in the Mail on Sunday , in which the former mayor of Doncaster, a man who helped Miliband become the town's MP, claims that Miliband and Balls knew a year early that the economic crash of 2008 was coming and concealed this information from voters. Both urged prime minister Gordon Brown to call a snap Election in 2007 because 'the economy was about to fall off a cliff' and it was Labour's only hope of holding on to power, the paper says. Needless to say, this has given George Osborne reason to start banging on about the economy again. Plus ca change…

The claim, when laid out in 64-point headlines is a damaging one on the surface, though somewhat counterintuitive. If they had really been so sure of a crash surely there would have been an election in 2007 after all. Labour folk were on Twitter last night brandishing the hashtag #stuffEdknowsinadvance fondly hoping that their leader can predict next week's lottery results. They point out that the ex-mayor Martin Winter has left the Labour party.

Likely to be more damaging in the long run are the details which contribute to the notion abroad with voters that Miliband is an odd cove. When he was seeking selection, Miliband stayed with the Winter family, for a period of time the MoS delights in telling us was "nine and a half weeks" (images you don't need on a Sunday morning). During that time "he destroyed a carpet after accidentally setting fire to the office he was using – then gave the couple a £25 Muslim prayer mat as a replacement", "nearly missed a meeting with Brown when he locked himself in another house" and "was given a humiliating lesson in economics by the Winters' ten-year-old daughter after 'patronising' the Winter children".

Labour will go on a full election war footing today, with the shadow cabinet moving to the party's headquarters at Brewer's Green in London. The Observer reveals that Ed Balls and Harriet Harman have fought successful rearguard actions to join the top team of eight who will decide all Labour strategy. The Sunday Times says Labour are planning to replace tuition fees with a graduate tax.

There may be further trouble ahead for Miliband this week. The SNP is plotting a vote on the future of Trident nuclear deterrent. Labour is officially committed to replacing all four boats but the whips have told my colleague James Lyons that more than 50 of his MPs could oppose replacing the ageing submarine and missiles system. 

  • A ComRes poll for The Independent on Sunday and Sunday Mirror has turned two common assumptions on their head this morning, suggesting that voters think more favourably of the Conservative party's brand than they do of David Cameron himself – or the Labour party.

  • A Panelbase poll for the Scottish Sunday Times has Labour narrowing the gap behind the SNP to 10 points, but still losing half their seats to the nationalists. And in the first of a regular series of gutsy predictions Peter Kellner, the doyen of British pollsters, suggests that the Tories will end up as the largest party in Westminster on the morning of May 8.

The good news for Miliband? Cameron might struggle to form a coalition and Miliband could still end up as prime minister. That should have Martin Winter choking on hiscornflakes...

Friday, 16 January 2015

Green and Pleasant Land..


Yesterday it was predicted that the Green surge would take their membership past Ukip within a week - it appears to have taken them just a day. They look likely to have overtaken the Liberal Democrats by Monday - and they're level with Nick Clegg's party in today's Poll of Polls. The Green surge increasingly looks like the real deal.

Downing Street's calculation is that the more the PM talks about Natalie Bennett and the Green Party in general, the worse it is for Ed Miliband's hopes in May. It's certainly forcing the Labour leader away from the issues that he wants to fight the election on: the end of his four-year silence on development issues and his more vocal commitment the return to his pre-2010 patch of climate change are both reported as attempts to shore up his left flank.

For some Labour MPs it all looks worryingly similar to the failed anti-Ukip strategy - "Ukip are right. Don't vote for them." - pursued by the Conservatives in recent years. The trouble for the Opposition is that three years since that Ukip breakthrough in Eastleigh neither they nor the Conservatives have come up with a particular effective response to Mr Farage, and there is still little sign so far that they will be any more successful in curtailing the rise of Ms Bennett. 

But the big worry for Labour is what it suggests about the endurance of the Liberal Democrats. One of the reasons to remain relatively bullish about the Opposition's prospects in May is it looked likely that Nick Clegg's party will collapse outside of the seats they hold, to the benefit of Labour, but that sitting Liberal Democrats will keep their places in Conservative contests. If the Green surge and the fragmentation of the Liberal vote endures, as now looks increasingly likely, then the prospect for significant Tory gains, and a cushion against the Ukip factor, is no longer as remote as Labour might wish.   


  

A LITTLE HELP FROM HIS FRIENDS

The US and the UK will create a joint "cyber squad" of spies to tackle the growing threat of terrorists plotting online attacks on the West, Peter Dominiczak reports from Washington. But the Guardian's James Ball has got hold of a secret US report from 2009 showing that the encryption technologies that the PM is now keen to ban are vital to preventing cyber-attacks from Russia, China and criminal gangs.  

SENTAMU VS JINGO

The immigration debate has descended into "jingoistic nonsense", John Sentamu has warned. "The whole nation - not just the politiciains - has got to have a mature debate," the Archbishop said. "At the moment it is one party telling another 'we are going to do it better than you are'." John Bingham has the story.  

AID

"Whitehall's £1bn spree to spend foreign aid" is our splash. Civil servants spent £1 billion on humanitarian programmes in war-torn Syria and the earthquake-hit Philippines in the last two months of 2013 as Dfid's 0.7% budget allocation had not yet been spent. (Further cash also went to Bill Gates' foundation to tackle Aids, tuberculosis and malaria.) "This proves the folly of binding targets which set out how much you have to spend irrespective of need," Sir Peter Luff says. 

SNAP, CRACKLE, [REDACTED]

TV advertising for foods that were high in food and sugar would be banned until after the watershed under a Labour government, Andy Burnham has announced. In the Times, Lucy Fisher reports that Labour's health team were forced to tone down plans for minimum pricing on booze and restrictions to the visibility of alcohol in supermarkets under pressure from senior Labour MPs who feared the ban would look draconian and alienate business. 

GRANITA REVISITED?

George Osborne has signalled his support for Boris Johnson in the event of a leadership contest after Conservative MPs made it clear that they did not regard the Chancellor as a realistic contender to succeed David Cameron, Sam Coates reports in the Times. 

ONE MILLION LOST VOTERS

Ed Miliband will today brand the disappearance of almost a million people from the electoral roll a "scandal" and will launch a campaign to register young people to vote ahead of the 20th April deadline. "The missing million voters" is the Indy's splash, while the i opts for "Missing: 1 million voters". 

THIS WAS DEFINITELY A GOOD IDEA

Do you like politics and obscure references to mid-Noughties social trends? Then you'll enjoy this retelling of the Coalition years through the medium of lines from the hit comedy Peep Show. Have a lovely weekend.


You can get in touch with me by pressing "reply" or on Twitter.  Our cartoon is the work of Christian Adams - a gallery of his work is available here. 

 

HOW HAVE THE POLLS MOVED IN THE PAST MONTH?

16.01.15

Conservatives 32% Labour 33% Liberal Democrat 7% Ukip 15% Greens 7%
LATEST POLLS:

TNS-BMRB: Conservatives 28% Labour 35% Liberal Democrat 6% Ukip 18% Green 5%

IpsosMori: Conservatives 33% Labour 34% Liberal Democrat 8% Ukip 11% Green 8%

YouGov:  Conservatives 32% Labour 32% Liberal Democrat 6% Ukip 15% Green 8%

TOO MANY TWEETS... 

@DavidMills73: I think I'd be more likely to join ISIS than the Greens

COMMENT

Jeremy Warner - The Enlightenment must be defended - or we'll be sorry

Fraser Nelson - The Tories are treating their proudest boast as a dirty secret

From elsewhere

Gaby Hinsliff - A teacher has sex with a 16-year-old girl, and he is a victim? Please (Guardian)

Philip Stephens -  Fear of defence cuts and Brexit weaken Britain in America (FT)


AGENDA 

1200 SHEFFIELD: Ed Miliband speech to students in Sheffield. 

TODAY IN PARLIAMENT

Commons: 0930

Local Government (Religious etc. Observances) Bill - Report stage.

Control of Offshore Wind Turbines Bill - Second reading.

Asylum (Time Limit) Bill - Second reading.

Bat Habitats Regulation Bill - Second reading.

Employment Rights Bill - Second reading.

Energy (Buildings and Reduction of Fuel Use) Bill - Second reading.

Houses in Multiple Occupation (Energy Performance Certificates and Minimum Energy Efficiency Standards) Bill - Second reading.

International Trade Agreements (Scrutiny) Bill - Second reading.

Railways (Public Sector Operators) Bill - Second reading.

Low Pay Commission (National Minimum Wage) Bill - Second reading .

Sugar in Food and Drinks (Targets, Labelling and Advertising) Bill - Second reading.

A short debate on the effect of the adoption of sewers on the home improvement industry.

Lords: 1000

Assisted Dying Bill [HL] - Committee of the whole House (Day 2).