Thursday, 6 September 2012

Cameron's building..


BREAKING: David Cameron was just on Daybreak. 

On the Cabinet reshuffle, he denied causing the ministers he sacked to cry. He also stressed that there are as many women in the Cabinet (four) as there were before. 

On the burglar shooting case, he said burglary is a “violent and despicable crime” and that while he had not seen the full case in question, burglars should go to prison. 

He also lavished praise on his wife, but said she’s unlikely to take the stage like Michelle Obama because she’s “not obsessed with politics”. 

Meanwhile, Nick Clegg was on Today. He said the country is not building enough new homes and that government will direct major resources at the problem. The new legislation provides for Government guarantees of up to £40 billion of major infrastructure projects and up to £10 billion for new homes. 

On Heathrow, he said “our position is very clear”. There will be no consent for a third runway from Clegg. 

DAVE’S BUILDING PLANS

David Cameron and Nick Clegg will appear together later to present their proposals for relaxing planning rules to stimulate housing growth. The opening salvo is our splash today, and briefed elsewhere too, namely that there will be a temporary suspension on rules governing home extensions.

Current restrictions will be lifted until 2015, allowing homeowners to double the size of their proposed extension, and without having to go through a cumbersome application process. The hope is that it will act as a useful turbo boost to the building industry. Mr Cameron will reinforce the point by visiting a building site.

Dig deeper though and interesting themes are emerging from the reshuffle, which has proved to be more revealing and worthy of dissection than we initially realised. Forget a U-turn on Heathrow, a more significant one is being prepared it seems: the Guardian mentions that the fiscal pressure on the Chancellor is such that ministers say the ring-fence around Health and International Development spending can no longer hold. The appointment of Jeremy Hunt and Justine Greening to those posts should be seen as the precursor to abandoning the Tory pledge to protect spending in those areas. Now that would be sport.

TEARS BEFORE BEDTIME

One of the most interesting titbits to land in the papers is James Forsyth’srevelation in the Spectator that Dave made three of his ministers cry. Sam Coates’s piece in the Times is packed with juicy details. 

Apparently, Cheryl Gillan and Bob Neill were two of the folk to burst into tears (although there are conflicting accounts).  

Dominic Raab and Ben Wallace turned down offers to be in the Whips Office - sources are warning that this rules them out of promotions in future. 

Caroline Spelman is said to have openly challenged the PM’s decision to sack her from the Environment brief, demanding a full explanation. When the PM suggested that the botched sell-off of State-owned forests was the driving factor, Mrs Spelman turned the tables on him, blaming him for agreeing the sale in the first place and then unexpectedly announcing the U-turn at the dispatch box.

Justine Greening is understood to have shouted at Dave, and Baroness Warsi turned down both the Commonwealth and Equalities brief. 

Must have been pretty brutal (no wonder Dave’s thinking about “butch” behaviour). He’s upset a lot of folk despite now trying to squeeze an extra nine seats around the Cabinet table (he’s created 32 jobs  despite there only being 23 full places). He has also dished out honours to placate others. You can read the full list of ministers post-reshuffle here. 

BEST OF ENEMIES

Despite keeping his job, Michael Gove is also thought to be unhappy. He put on a display of chumminess yesterday, sharing a car with his new deputy David Laws and ushering the Lib Dem into No 10 ahead of him. We were assured that they are best mates. But the Times (£) reports great unhappiness among Mr Gove's friends that he has been saddled with a potential meddler in the place of the more placid Sarah Teather.

RUNWAY POLICY

The Heathrow fudge-o-rama rattles on. This morning’s FT (£) report that any decision on a third runway has been shelved until after the 2015 election. The decision perturbed Boris Johnson who has become increasingly vocal in his disgruntlement. According to the Mayor of London, the hesitation was: “A fudge that will cost business dear.”

Both Labour and the Conservatives have committed to the Davies enquiry on London’s airport capacity, but with Cameron assuring the House of Commons yesterday that he “will not break his manifesto pledge”, there is unlikely to be any movement in the life of this parliament.

THE DEATH OF MODERNISATION?

All this drama got me thinking yesterday, does this Rightward shift mark the end of Tory modernisation? Old fashioned Toryism looks to be back in action (Greg Knight is back in the Whips' Office, for goodness sake). Climate change is in the hands of a sceptic, Heathrow in play, Justine Greening has been sidelined, Nick Herbert has left. 

Suddenly, Steve Hilton's departure is explained. Mr Cameron will doubtless deny that modernisation has been dropped, but I wonder if we will look back at this reshuffle as the moment when the Prime Minister went Tory on us. You can read more on my blog here. 

TWO ED’ED MONSTER 

Meanwhile, on the other side of the political fence, Ed Miliband and Ed Balls are due to make a joint appearance at the London Stock Exchange (Mr Miliband is speaking at 11.15am). Bosom buddies, you see. Mr Balls makes this point emphatically in an interview with the Indy today. He says: "There is no argument or row…neither Ed nor I are being soft on bank regulation…"

Still no detail until next year, though. Mr Balls does make it clear that he is not keen on Vince’s mansion tax (he wants something more aggressive - a “serious” proposal for a high-value property tax, not a one-off). He is keen on the Business Secretary himself, however. He has already started talks with him. Mr Balls said:

"The person thinking seriously about this was not Nick Clegg but Vince Cable. I feel for Vince and the extent of his frustration [with the Coalition]…but if he wants to channel those frustrations into discussions about how we can achieve growth and jobs in the future I'll start discussions with him tomorrow".

Dave must be very pleased he put Michael Fallon and Matthew Hancock in BIS to keep an eye on Vince now. 

MILIBAND’S ZEN 

But Mr Balls isn’t the only one giving interviews. Mr Miliband has given one to the New Statesmen revealing that he is a Zen-like creature (clearly doesn’t care for the “butch” qualities the PM thinks he should have). 

He told the magazine that he didn’t take his phone on holiday, read the papers or watch the news. He told people that if they wanted to contact him, they would have to call his wife, Justine. 

IMMIGRATION CHAOS

Mr Miliband needs Zen when it comes to picking up sticky issues for Labour - namely immigration. And Frank Field isn’t making it much easier for him. He’s teamed up with Nicholas Soames to rail against mass immigration in the Mail and the Sun. 

RESHUFFLE MEAN TO GREENS

The reshuffle has left green Tories feeling nervous. A report in today’s FT(£) quotes one saying:

“A number of us are concerned at Owen Paterson going to Defra and John Hayes going to energy...We are not sure where the Prime Minister stands now.”

Tim Yeo is also quoted lamenting that it would be “electorally harmful” for the Conservatives to drop their interest in a low carbon economy. TheIndependent, meanwhile, details how the Lib Dems are unhappy at the arrival of sceptics into the green swamp. Although green issues have long divided the grassroots and parts of the parliamentary party, this is the first sign of a green fault line between Conservatives and Lib Dems at cabinet level.

BOO-GATE

Following the chorus of boos which greeted George Osborne’s star turn as a dispenser of medals at the Paralympics, aides from No 10 have confirmed that the Prime Minister will not be following him. 

Meanwhile, Ed Miliband has added oil to the fire. He is quoted in today’sDaily Mail saying that the jeering crowd “spoke for Britain”. Only Jeremy Hunt (who will, no doubt, prove popular) and Hugh Robertson are still due to hand out medals. 

VETERANS’ TSAR

Former tax exile and millionaire party donor Lord Ashcroft has joined the government as David Cameron’s veterans’ tsar. (You can read theTelegraph’s report here). It is not yet clear whether Lord Ashcroft will be paid, answer questions in the House of Lords, or even have a desk at the Ministry of Defence. Civil servants promise details will be “ironed out” in the coming days. More “building in process” then? Jeez. 

SWEATY GEORGE 

And finally, with an economy to fix who could blame George for choosing to start his morning with a jog around St James’s Park as he did yesterday? (There’s rather sweaty photo available here). The mood of quiet solitude, however, was dented when the photographers detected two close protection officers following him in a Land Rover. Oh dear. 

TWEETS AND TWITS

Tom Harris is less than impressed with David Cameron’s choice of put-down for Ed Balls’ coffee bearer:

“@TomHarrisMP Seriously? We're using "butch" as a compliment now, and not in a vaguely ironic Village People kind of way? #youcanhangoutwithalltheboys”

TOP COMMENT

In The Telegraph

Jeremy Warner: Boo the Tories all you like but they're right about saving the economy 

Sue Cameron: Whitehall's new boys given a helping hand

Chris Skidmore: The new Jerusalem should look like Palo Alto

Leader: Dither, not decision, on airport expansion

Best of the rest

Stephen Glover in the Mail: Is there a secret reason why Cameron has promoted a minister who should’ve been sacked for misconduct months ago? 

Andrew Gimson in the Guardian: David Cameron: a leader with no direction 

Camilla Cavendish in the Times (£): Hunt for health - it's a gamble worth taking 

Joan Smith in the Independent: We need female ministers not political wives 

THE AGENDA

Today: Michael Gove and the Institute of Physics announces the continuation of a scheme to recruit physics teachers

Today: Vince Cable is to visit Honda to mark twenty years of production at the company's plant in Swindon

10am: Boris Johnson meets Team London Ambassadors and Locog Games Makers to thank them for their service. Peninsular Square, North Greenwich Arena, London

10.30am: Business, Innovation and Skills questions

11am: Home Office Permanent Secretary Dame Helen Ghosh and Theresa May give evidence to MPs on the Olympics security row. Committee room 15, House of Commons, Westminster

11.15am: Ed Miliband speech at the Policy Network’s "Quest for Growth" conference. He will be joined afterwards by Ed Balls for a question and answers section. The London Stock Exchange, 10 Paternoster Square

12pm: The Bank of England announces its decision on interest rates and quantitative easing 

6.30pm: George Osborne gives a speech to the CBI Scotland dinner. Hilton Hotel, 1 William Street

Wednesday, 5 September 2012

The New Team..


BREAKING: The new Tory Chairman Grant Shapps was just on the Today programme discussing Heathrow expansion, his new role and the cabinet reshuffle. 


On Heathrow expansion, he said “we are dooming ourselves to economic failure” if we aren’t open to the debate over Heathrow expansion. Although he said there’s no chance of the Tories breaking their manifesto commitment not to expand Heathrow... in this parliament. 

On the reshuffle - and Andrew Lansley’s move, in particular - he said: “eventually people move on”. 

On Chris Grayling’s promotion and the shift in policy this could cause, he simply said “people are different”. 

On IDS’s refusal to move jobs, he said he could imagine that the PM might suggest that someone who had “done so well” in DWP could be put to good use elsewhere. 

On the cabinet as a whole, he said: “This is the team that can deliver”. 

POLITE APPLAUSE 

Polite applause is the best way of describing reaction across the papers this morning. Some of the detail is admired but the consensus is that moving people won't matter as much as implementing policies: if these are Mr Cameron's doers, then let's see what they can do. Persuading Paul Deighton to come aboard as Minister for Economic Delivery is a coup. And Michael Fallon will be a powerful voice - if you missed it, have a look at his turn with Paxo last night - as Minister for Growth. 

As I argue in my column, indecision is our biggest problem, and all the big decisions come back to the Prime Minister: he's the one who has to show he's not a ditherer. There's a consensus that it was a bad day for Nick Clegg (to which a Tory tells the Mail: “who cares?”), and that George Osborne suffered a setback when IDS refused to budge. And we learn that Patrick McLoughlin is afraid of flying.

If you want some good detail you would do worse than reading Nicholas Watt on the Tories and Patrick Wintour on the Lib Dems in the Guardian. Their pieces are full of juicy detail, including the Chancellor's delight that he “got his man” in the shape of Andrew Mitchell (mark my words, there is going to be sport to be had here), Danny Finkelstein's role in scuppering Mr Osborne's cunning plan to shift IDS, and the prospect that Justine Greening will be out for revenge. (A Tory says: "You don't want to cross Justine. She will store this reshuffle away. In years to come she may well exact her revenge.") 

But what fascinates Westminster has no resonance beyond. What matters is what the Government does, and we will now focus on tomorrow's plans for announcements from David Cameron and Nick Clegg on the infrastructure and regeneration plans. 

Yesterday, curiously, there seemed to be uncertainty in Downing Street over whether they will appear together or separately. As Patrick Wintour points out, “the Rose Garden is now closed until further notice”. 

THE PAPERS’ HIGHLIGHTS

Most of the headlines are a variation on the Guardian’s “Cameron’s right turn”, but the i and the Mirror take digs at the PM’s timidity in not moving the big players. The i’s splash reads: “The mouse that roared” and the Mirror’s “SQUEAK!” , which appears next to a rather good photoshop of Mr Cameron dressed as a mouse.

The papers have all picked out similar angles too: Jeremy Hunt’s promotion after the BSkyB saga attracts a lot of attention. The Mail’s big picture of him shrugging his shoulders next to the headline “Happy Hunt shakes off BSkyB cloud” says a lot. 

Many conclude that this is evidence that the PM likes to keep his friends close, but in my column I suggest that it’s tempting to see this as the hand of Mr Osborne - transferring a potential rival to a department that is toxic for Tories. 

Likewise, IDS’s refusal to move departments has been homed in on as an example of the PM’s weakness. Yesterday, Downing Street was on the defensive about it yesterday, saying it was merely courtesy to a former leader. My view is that the Prime Minister blinked rather than antagonise his already fractious Right wing. 

HEATHROW 

The Heathrow row inevitably drew attention with the removal of Justine Greening as Transport Secretary. Boris Johnson couldn’t help himself - he accused the PM of a covert attempt to back the “mad” third runway plan. You can read more here. 

Danny Finkelstein, however, argues that her removal has nothing to do with Heathrow. He says: “It was because, in a very important job, she hadn’t proven the easiest colleague to work with, nor the most impressive.” 

COUNTRYSIDE LUDDITES 

A story definitely worth checking out is the Mail’s on the new planning minister Nick Boles who considers countryside campaigners to be Luddites. This one might gather steam. 

PAPERS’ VIEWS

Michael Deacon’s sketch sums up much of the papers’ attitudes towards the reshuffle: 

“To judge by his appointments, the Prime Minister has a keen sense of what voters are thinking. Obviously they’re very happy with the state of the economy, there are loads of jobs about, and business is booming, so no need to change the Chancellor or Business Secretary.

On the other hand, families across the land think of little else but international development and the timetabling of government business in the Commons, so it was vital to get those areas sorted out.”

Our leader gives Dave a chance to prove himself: “Overall, this is not a reshuffle that changes a great deal. It is the Government’s policies that matter, and especially how it proposes to kick-start an ailing economy. Mr Cameron has his new team; now we wait to see what they intend to do.”

Elsewhere, the leaders fall predictably into line - the Mail welcoming the Rightward turn and the Guardian warning against it. 

NERD ALERT

And for those dissatisfied by the papers’ level of geeky Village detail, Bell Pottinger, the lobbying firm, has created a dedicated Reshuffle 2012website. It includes analysis of everything from the possible impact on policy to quirky facts, including: 

“DID YOU KNOW? 

David Willetts’ ministerial responsibility for the UK Space Agency and the National Measurement Office mean he is the Minister for Space and Time.”

TWEETS AND TWITS

Tom Harris ‏reacts to Tom Chivers’ Telegraph blog discussing the new Health Secretary’s penchant for homeopathy: 

“RT @benedictbrogan: Hunt on #homeopathy: Department says 'his views have moved on'. < What, TWO parts in a million? That's an OVERDOSE!”

I think many would agree, Tom. 

TOP COMMENT

In The Telegraph

Benedict Brogan: David Cameron's Cabinet reshuffle: What if the real roadblock to recovery is the man at the top? 

Allister Heath: Cameron’s musical chairs won’t do anything to mend the economy

Dominic Raab: Hard graft can make Britain great again

Leader: A new team – but the problems don’t change

Best of the rest

Tim Montgomerie in the Mail: Cameron's reshuffle was clever, but will it be enough to revive his premiership? 

James Purnell in the FT: Cameron's reshuffle was clever, but will it be enough to revive his premiership? 

Daniel Finkelstein in the Times: Obstacles removed. Now get on and govern 

Simon Jenkins in the Guardian: What a reshuffle. It's the return of Brown and Blair 

THE AGENDA

Today: Nick Clegg visits a school

Today: Michael Gove gives an update on the number of Academy schools

10am: Boris Johnson gives a speech at a conference on marketing impact of Paralympics. London Media Centre, One Great George Street

11.30am:  Cabinet Office

12pm: David Cameron at PMQs

3pm: David Cameron's revamped Cabinet meets for the first time at Downing Street

3.15pm: Home Office Permanent Secretary Dame Helen Ghosh, UKBA head Rob Whiteman and Border Force chief Brian Moore give evidence to MPs on the Public Accounts Committee. Committee room 15, House of Commons, Westminster

Tuesday, 4 September 2012

Reshuffle day..



The reshuffle is underway and seeping out. There is much excitement, but only because it's Dave's first, not because it will be a big one. With luck there will be a surprise, and most reshuffles always have an unexpected moment, usually when a minister refuses to budge. To recap the moves so far, reported and speculated:

- Sayeeda Warsi has outed herself, as it were, on Twitter, and is no longer Tory chairman. We don't yet know whether she gets something else.

- Today says Kenneth Clarke is out as Justice Secretary. Rumours are flying that he’s to become a minister without portfolio with an emphasis on economy. How will that work?

- I gather Eric Pickles joined the Quad to discuss planning yesterday afternoon, so presumably he isn't going anywhere.

- The papers seem certain David Laws will get Sarah Teather's slot at Education, with a roving brief (whether she gets something in return is unclear). Apparently there was a dispute with Nick Clegg over whether he could have an extra minister or had to make room for Mr Laws.

- Nick Boles has cancelled a speech today, encouraging speculation that he will be promoted. Matt Hancock is mentioned, of course.

- 'Thrasher' Mitchell was confirmed as Chief Whip - the joy! - by No 10 last night. "George gets his chief whip," the Guardian reports, reflecting Thrasher's  proximity to the Chancellor. Mr Mitchell (or, as some Tory MPs are already calling him, Christian Grey) famously invited Mr Osborne to dinner at the height of the leadership campaign when he was running David Davis' doomed operation (one minister told me disobligingly yesterday that DD would have done better without Mr Mitchell in charge).ConHome seem pleased. Co-editor Paul Goodman says Dave is right to "restore the firepower" to the Whips Office. The FT headline describes him as "Popular choice" and "widely respected", which is one way of putting it. 

- In the self-reshuffling department, Zac Goldsmith has promised to resign and force a by-election if the Government changes course on Heathrow.

- The Times reports that this morning's Cabinet has been cancelled, to allow Mr Cameron to make his moves. 

- Various names touted for chairman: Grant 'Michael Green' Shapps, of course, but also Jeremy Hunt.

- The fate of Justine Greening is one to watch: Patrick McLoughlin is being tipped to replace her, so where does she go? Out altogether? Bit harsh? 

- It also seems Caroline Spelman was told last night that it's over for her. And there's a consensus forming around the departure of Andrew Lansley.

You can follow the events as they happen today on our live blog here. 

PLANNING PROBLEMS 

Meanwhile, Dave’s proposed reforms to planning law are already starting to backfire. Malcolm Sharp, the president of the Planning Officers’ Society,told us that the Government has misjudged the problem: the economy - not red tape - is the obstacle to building more homes. 

And that’s not the only hiccup. The FT reports that Eric Pickles is making noises too. His spokesman said yesterday that changes to the greenbelt were permitted only in "exceptional circumstances", which doesn’t sound very radical. But if the speculation is correct, he’s radical enough for Dave.

THE PRICE OF UNPOPULARITY 

His advisers were a bit nervous about it and with hindsight it was an obvious risk, but the Chancellor will be smarting from his reception at the Paralympics yesterday (you can watch it here ). It's a good thing Mr Osborne has a realistic view of his popularity. As he explained on Marr on Sunday, it would be odd if he wasn't the most unpopular politician in Britain. So you could argue that the more he is booed, the more he is doing a good job on the austerity front. If only it were that simple...

THE DUNCAN-ATOR

It’s worth noting that Alan Duncan is backing the burglar shooters. Bold and will go down well with the grassroots. Not sure I can imagine the PM saying the same, though. You can read more here. 

YELLOW PERIL? 

The Lib Dems will note two polls today in the Independent and Sun that suggest the party would do better if Vince Cable was in charge instead of Nick Clegg. But not by much. YouGov in the Sun says the party would go from 8 per cent to - wait for it - 11 per cent, while ComRes in the Indy says rating would go from 14 per cent to 18 per cent, enough to take it from 23 to 39 seats.

GREEN LEADER

And finally, the Greens unveiled their new leader: Natalie Bennett, an Australian-born former Guardian journalist and United Nations advisor. She boasts that she’s the only party leader who can shear sheep - just what we’ve always wanted. More information is available in the Indy here. 

TWEETS AND TWITS 

"@tom_watson: Hi @louisemensch - how's it feel being free?! Just wondering - is it your pic on the side of this toolkit? http://www.howtowriteanewsletter.com/newcomer26.php"

If only it had been one of Grant Shapps’s - sorry, I mean, Michael Green’s - toolkits.

POLL WATCH

Latest ComRes/Independent polling: Conservatives 35%, Labour 42%, Lib Dems 12%, Others 11%

TOP COMMENT

In The Telegraph

Mary Riddell: The cracks between Ed Miliband and Ed Balls could swallow Labour’s hopes

Liz Truss: We must shift science out of the geek ghetto

Leader: Mr Cameron’s old rival shows him the way

Leader: Still not fit for purpose

Best of the rest

Steve Richards in the Independent: It's not the names that matter but the policies

Rachel Sylvester in the Times: Game changer? No, more an echo chamber

Polly Toynbee in the Guardian: These angry Tories can't see what 'no alternative' means

Jana Ganesh in the Financial Times: Time for Britain to rediscover the art of coalition

THE AGENDA

Today: Theresa May will make an announcement on police pension reform

Today: Alan Duncan will attend a Friends of Yemen meeting in Saudi Arabia

Today: Agriculture and Food Minister Jim Paice will announce measures to help farmers

2.30pm: Foreign Office questions