Wednesday, 13 June 2012

Morning briefing..


COALITION AT WAR

The Coalition is at war over Nick Clegg's decision to allow his MPs a free vote on the investigation of Jeremy Hunt.  We've splashed on it -  as has the Guardian, its splash reads:  "Clegg leaves Cameron high and dry", and the Mail who lead with  "Clegg accused of 'act of war'" .

Nick Clegg's decision to desert Dave over Jeremy Hunt is a shock to the Coalition. He has an eye to his appearance at Leveson at 10am today, but it also reflects his long standing distaste for the way the Tories abased themselves before Rupert Murdoch, and his anger at not being consulted.

We hear there were several shouting matches between him and Dave. Mr Clegg is seething over the way the Prime Minister rushed to clear his friend Mr Hunt over the BSkyB business by ruling out a referral to Sir Alex Allan. But is he justified in his anger? Or is all of this just a manifestation of a truth about the Coalition, namely that internal party affairs are just that, a matter for the individual leaders?

Dave might say that he kept out of the Chris Huhne business, recognising that it was a matter for Mr Clegg alone, and in turn was entitled to dispose of Mr Hunt as he saw fit. By that measure of course Mr Clegg is perfectly entitled to let Mr Hunt hang: why should the Lib Dems help the Tories with their dirty business?

Some will say this isn't about whether he should support the Culture Secretary, but whether he is obliged to support the Coalition under any circumstances. The Agreement says nothing about circumstances like these. Objectively, it is hard to see how Mr Cameron can expect Mr Clegg to back him, in particular as he didn't consult the Lib Dem leader in the first place.

Where does it leave relations this morning? "Business-like," No 10 folk say, which sounds ominous. "It's part of the Coalition rough and tumble. We'll all get over it." Will Nick Clegg sit next to Dave at PMQs? Will Tory MPs turn on their Lib Dem colleagues?

Today's vote on a Labour motion is not binding, and the Government will win it (the Tories are taking it quite seriously - they're even dragging one poor MP back from honeymoon). Mr Clegg will have made his point. The public, already indifferent to Leveson, will scarcely notice. But it will weaken Mr Cameron's defence of Mr Hunt. And it will leave a bad taste among Tories - and perhaps even those sanguine folk in Downing Street - who will conclude that Mr Clegg is not a man to go tiger shooting with. But that's the point: he never was. If the Tories have any sense they will recognise that it's only showbiz, and the Coalition is an alliance of convenience with a deadly enemy, not a friendship or a pact of loyalty.

NO INTEREST IN A REFERENDUM?

But the Government are unlikely to find much party support for its latest claim. Downing Street are briefing that 'the people don't want a referendum' - didn't they see last week's Times' poll showing that 80 per cent of people did? This will anger a lot of Tory MPs, not to mention voters. You can read our report here .

But Daniel Finkelstein in the Times  preempts the storm, warning us not to get referendum happy in his column. He says we should know where Europe is going before we call for a vote.

No 10's view is surprising, given that George is busy stoking up Greek exit tensions (something that he hinted will force a referendum).  The FT has splashed on this, using the Chancellor's comments at a business event yesterday, he said:

"I ultimately don't know whether Greece needs to leave the euro in order for the eurozone to do the things necessary to make their currency survive...  I just don't know whether the German government requires Greek exit to explain to their public why they need to do certain things like a banking union, eurobonds and things in common with that."

The President of Greece's Syriza coalition has other ideas though. In a column for the FT he says he will keep Greece in the eurozone and restore growth. At least he's optimistic...

George also got animated about tax cuts at yesterday's event - he warned businesses that they must shout louder for the merits of lower taxes or the Government will be unable to cut the top rate of income tax to 40p. The Times  has splashed on this with "Chancellor to business: back us on lower taxes".

IT'S A FALKLAND AFFAIR

Meanwhile, Dave is encouraging other referendumselsewhere - namely in the Falkland Islands. He's pleased that they're going to vote on whether or not to remain British. The hope is that a vote in favour will garner international support against Argentina's claim to the islands.  You can read our report  here.

MANSION HOUSE

The Times is also previewing George's Mansion House speech tomorrow. It says:

"In his Mansion House speech the Chancellor is expected to back the concept of a banking union in the 17-member region while insisting that Britain will not take part. Mr Osborne is expected to insist on safeguards to protect the UK financial sector amid warnings from his own party that Europe's ambitions could damage the City."

GAY MARRIAGE

And as if the Coalition wasn't in a delicate state,  Desmond Swayne and Crispin Blunt have come out in favour of allowing churches to marry gay couples. An interesting move by Crispin Blunt,  who recently left his wife because he was gay. Does he have re-marriage plans?  

We have a column by  George Carey, a former archbishop, saying that this threatens the bonds between Church and state. He also questions the Government's competence, saying:

"The enduring legacy of the consultation on same-sex marriage may be to raise questions about ministerial competence. The Church of England's response points out a number of matters where ministers' judgment can be questioned. Crucially, it shows that proposals for same-sex marriage would create mutually contradictory versions of matrimony within English law."

The Mail's leader has come out staunchly against the plans, saying:  "How can he [David Cameron] fuss with this irrelevance, when he has yet to do anything about honouring his promise to give families and social stability a boost by recognising traditional marriage in the tax system? This is displacement politics of the most shameful kind. The U-turn can't come soon enough."

CIVIL SERVICE WAR

And the war with the opposition within rumbles on. The Times  reports that radical reforms to transform Whitehall staff into professional "purchasers" of private services are to be announced next week. Tensions are high though - the Government will"flounder and fail" if David Cameron fails to give them his full backing.

HOT SNACK ATTACK 

And finally, Cheryl Cole has revealed she would have gone hungry if the pasty tax had been introduced when she was a teenager. She told  the Sun: "It was ridiculous. I would have been penniless as a teenager — and hungry — if I'd been taxed every time I had a hot pasty."

How someone so slender was raised on fatty snacks is marvel, really.

TWEETS AND TWITS

Louise Mensch explains her membership of Labour Party in the '90s:

"@LouiseMensch: RT @James_Macintyre: Major: In many ways Blair was "to the right of me". <~~ exactly why I joined New Lab in 1996"

POLL WATCH

Latest YouGov/The Sun results: Conservatives 33%, Labour 43%, Lib Dems 8%, UKIP 8%

Overall government approval rating:  -35

TOP COMMENT

In The Telegraph

Benedict Brogan:  Osborne can only pray as the storm in Europe rages

Louise Mensch:  Toxic trolls should have no hiding place

Leader:  Winsor offers the police a professional future

Leader:  A waste of experience

Best of the rest

Alexis Tsipras in the Financial Times: I will keep Greece in the eurozone and restore growth

Daniel Finkelstein in the Times: If you want out, don't demand a vote too soon

Christina Patterson in the Independent: This gentle muddle of Church and State may be as good as it gets 

THE AGENDA

Today: Opposition day debate (first allotted day) on the referral of Jeremy Hunt to the Independent Adviser on Ministers' Interests

Today: Chris Grayling will announce the expansion of Mandatory Work Activity with a  boost of an extra £5m to create an additional 9,000 places

Today: Grant Shapps will set out proposals on social tenants on high salaries paying a fair level of rent for the privilege of living in a social home

Today: Andrew Mitchell is travelling to Washington DC for the US Aid conference

Today: Vince Cable will speak at The Investec Entrepreneurs' Summit. Intercontinental Park Lane, London

9.30am: Children's Minister Tim Loughton will launch a consultation on the principle of shared parenting following divorce or separation 

9.45am: Sports and Olympics Minister Hugh Robertson will publish the final update on the Olympic budget before the Games begin next month

10am: Nick Clegg and Alex Salmond give evidence to the Leveson Inquiry. The Royal Courts of Justice, The Strand, London

10am: Boris Johnson at London Mayor's Question Time. City Hall, The Queen's Walk, London

10am:Rebekah Brooks to appear in court. Court 1, Westminster Magistrates Court, 181 Marylebone Road, London

11.30am: Cabinet Office Questions

12pm: David Cameron at PMQs

1pm: Iain Duncan Smith gives speech on skills and youth unemployment at the IGD Skills Summit, Millennium Gloucester Hotel, London

4.30pm: Defence ministers Peter Luff and Nick Harvey give evidence to the Commons Scottish Affairs Committee on the potential impact of independence. Grimond Room, Portcullis House, London



Tuesday, 12 June 2012

Morning briefing..

GEORGE EMERGES UNSCATHED
 
The week remains dominated by Leveson, and the prospect of David Cameron giving evidence. No 10 has been boning up on the regulatory issues Lord Justice Leveson is particularly interested in. Mr Cameron has also been rehearsing his account of the hiring of Andy Coulson.

Today's papers are laced with a significant degree of scepticism about Gordon Brown's 'I know nothing' evidence. The Times, as you might expect, points out in its headline that he was under oath ("I didn't declare war on Murdoch, says Brown under oath"), the Guardian says he was emotional, and Quentin Letts demolishes his performance on 'Radio Loonshire'.

George Osborne emerges intact, his session attracting little comment and broadly favourable headlines. Downing Street will feel relieved that a difficult week has got off to a good start. In my blog , I've written about how Gordon helped him achieve this (angry men don't disguise their resentment well on TV). George in contrast looked at all times at ease – perhaps a little too much. He sounded as if he was having no difficulty giving straight answers.

Michael White's account in the Guardian is interesting, particularly on the publicity of Gordon's son's illness. He suggests that Gordon's appeal to "what any parent in the land" would have felt about the publicity was undermined by his subsequent admission that he later had 30 meetings with the Murdochs and their henchfolk, including parties and weddings.

In the Times, Hugo Rifkind writes that Gordon's evidence appears near crazy:

"In Gordon's world, papers decided they fancied a Tory government and then went hunting for stories about him throwing mobile phones at people. As though there were stories about simply everybody throwing phones at people, if you looked hard enough, but the Murdochs, Rothermeres and Barclays had just decreed that the ones about David Cameron ought to be hushed up."

STICKING PLASTER

And as ever the backdrop of the eurozone crisis continues. Yesterday's relief at the Spanish bailout has already subsided with Asian markets falling this morning.

In the Telegraph, Jeremy Warner isn't surprised, in his column, he's said that this latest solution will come apart in less than a month.

The FT (£) has splashed on an interview with José Manuel Barroso, President of the European Commission, saying that all 27 EU countries should submit their big banks to a single cross-border supervisor as part of a banking union to be enacted next year.

Bad, but can George keep blaming the eurozone for Britain's problems? The FT tackles this in its leader column, saying:

"In part, the debate is academic. Eurozone woes surely make things worse. UK spending cuts, taken by themselves, are a drag on growth too, as are high commodity prices. None of this suffices to conclude an argument about the best policy to pursue. Politicians should not pretend that it does."

You can keep up to date with events in the eurozone throughout the day on our live blog.

It's not just George who's looking to make decisions about Europe. In the Times (£), Rachel Sylvester reports that a Conservative Cabinet minister has said that "Europe is now in play in a way it hasn't been for a long, long time... All options are on the table and clearly withdrawal is one of the options."

PROPER CONSERVATIVES

In the Telegraph, Philip Johnston celebrates this new mood, focusing particularly on Theresa May announcement on immigration rules yesterday - as well as Eric Pickles's view on problem families.

He argues that "With its robust new policies, has the Tory party got over its fear of being portrayed as heartless?... That's more like it: the firm smack of a proper Conservative government."

And keeping this up is the best way to win the next election.

NANCY CAMERON

And of course, Cameron leaving his daughter, Nancy, in the pub has attracted lots of comment. The Guardian has a story summarising the scorn and sympathy here. It turns out an awful lot of journalists have also forgotten their children...

CHURCH SPLIT

The Telegraph, Times and the Guardian have all splashed on the Church's warning that it could split from the state. The church fear that government assurances about church protections will be ripped up by the European court.

You can read our report here.

NO REGIONAL PAY

A dissenting voice on regional pay has emerged from the Tory benches. We report that Guy Opperman, the only Tory MP in the north-east of England, has said the Chancellor's proposals would be unfair on public sector staff and not help the UK economy.

THE VOICE OF GOD

Pay and conditions are also a problem at the Treasury. Lord O'Donnell has warned that it is in "danger of being swamped by the pressures placed on it" and should consider receiving funding from the financial services industry.

In his first speech since being given a peerage, he warned that the Treasury is struggling to address the problems caused by the ongoing global financial turmoil. He said that the rate of staff turnover was "far too high and their pay levels too low". You can read more in our report here.

IN A PICKLE

And finally, it's worth noting that Eric Pickles's view on problem families yesterday has attracted a lot of attention from the Guardian. Polly Toynbee has dedicated her column to the " Tory vilification campaign against the poor" and the paper's leader column discusses his "poverty of argument".

I'm not sure Mr Pickles will be bother - I don't think he expected the Guardian to agree.

TWEETS AND TWITS

"@SarahBrownUK: Personally I am delighted that I did not go flying on the slippery, wet court steps on arrival #levenson #highheels"

She must also be delighted that Gordon didn't slip up either.

POLL WATCH

Latest YouGov/The Sun results: Conservatives 31%, Labour 45%, Lib Dems 9%, UKIP 9%

Overall government approval rating: -38

TOP COMMENT

In The Telegraph

Mary Riddell: For one day only at the Leveson Inquiry, the Iron and Rubber Chancellor double act

Philip Johnston: Be truly Conservative and the votes will come

Jeremy Warner: This latest euro fix will come apart in less than a month

Leader: Church and state collide over same-sex marriage

Best of the rest

Rachel Sylvester in the Times: It's mad: a euro vote with no clear question

Philip Stephens in the Financial Times: Cameron bids Europe a Churchillian goodbye

Dominic Lawson in the Independent: You can accuse the banks. But politicians should also be in the dock

Polly Toynbee in the Guardian: Tory vilification campaign against the poor is so clever

THE AGENDA

Today: David Cameron chairs weekly coalition Cabinet meeting

Today: Children's Minister Tim Loughton sets out proposals to free social workers from pointless bureaucracy to help them keep children safe from harm

Today: Caroline Lucas gives a speech at GMB Annual Congress. Brighton Centre, Brighton

9.30am: Nick Herbert and Tom Winsor, the Government's preferred candidate for the next Chief Inspector of Constabulary, will speak at a policing conference. Central Hall, Westminster, London

9.30am: Lynne Featherstone is to outline the results of the age discrimination consultation

9.45am: Ed Miliband, Sir John Major and Harriet Harman before Leveson Inquiry. Royal Courts of Justice, The Strand, London

10am: Remuneration experts give evidence to Treasury Select Committee on City pay. Committee Room 16, House of Commons, London

10.30am: Anne Milton appears before the Health Select Committee to discuss the Government's alcohol strategy. Committee Room 5, Palace of Westminster, London

10.30am: Former special advisers give evidence about the role to the Commons Public Administration Committee. Witnesses include Michael Jacobs (10 Downing St 2007-10), James O'Shaughnessy (10 Downing St 2010-11) and Duncan Brack (DECC 2010-12). Room 8, House of Commons

11am: Business, Innovation and Skills Committee takes evidence from David Willetts. Committee Room 6, Palace of Westminster, London

1pm: Proposals for backbench debates. Boothroyd Room, Portcullis House

2.15pm: Caroline Spelman appears before the Environmental Audit Committee to discuss the Rio+20 Summit. Thatcher Room, Portcullis House

2.30pm: Health Questions

Today: Financial Secretary to the Treasury Mark Hoban, Europe Minister David Lidington, and Lloyds Banking Group Chairman Sir Winfried Bischoff discuss the big challenges of the future. Nomura, 1 Angel Lane, London

4.45pm: Boris Johnson joins the Team London Ambassadors in a lifesaving training session. City Hall, London

5pm: Gus O'Donnell and his former counterpart in Australia Terry Moran debate 'Lessons from Leaders of Reform'. Institute for Government, 2 Carlton Gardens, London

5.30pm: Peers and MPs take part in the charity match of tug of war. The College Gardens, Great College Street, Westminster

6.05pm: Bank of England Deputy Governor for Financial Stability Paul Tucker gives a speech at the Investment Property Forum

Monday, 11 June 2012

Brogan's Brief...

GEORGE'S DIFFICULT SPRING

It is proving to be a difficult spring for George Osborne. Today he faces sniping from his own side and questions from Lord Leveson. The Chancellor will be on display - and potentially not in a flattering light - at the inquiry (he's on after Gordon Brown who starts at 10am).

This morning's headlines are uncomfortable for him. A small but vocal number of Tory MPs are pursuing a campaign against him which, they claim, reflects the disillusionment of a wider number of backbenchers who think the Chancellor no longer cuts the mustard. Following his intervention on Sunday when he warned that the euro crisis was putting Europe at risk of long term stagnation, his colleagues have attacked him for using the euro as an excuse for his poor performance.

Outspoken Eurosceptic Douglas Carswell started it with a blog post on his website Talk Carswell titled "The Chancellor has it 180 degrees wrong".  The Independent has an interview with him in today's paper. Mr Carswell makes some further stinging rebukes of Dave and George's administration - but also of Parliament calling it  "supine, spineless, dominated by spivery and spivs".

David Ruffley, another Tory MP and member of the Treasury Select Committee also added his concerns:  "We can't just say the eurozone is destroying confidence in the UK and nothing can be done."

The Treasury will doubtless point out that Mr Carswell hardly represents the Tory mainstream, but that would be to miss the point: his latest outburst is the public tip of a bigger iceberg.

We've put  "Stop blaming the eurozone crisis, Tories tell George Osborne" on the front page - as has the FT with "Osborne told to stop using eurozone alibi".  The story is also carried in the Mail and Guardian. The Mail has put a column by Alex Brummer beneath its story on this, saying "He can't blame Europe for all our problems".

The Chancellor gives his Mansion House speech on Thursday, which gives him a chance to turn things around. And it gets worse: have a look at what Grayson Perry says about him in  Mandrake.

Leveson will be gripping this week, at least for those in the village. Today it's one of Westminster's longest running grudges marches in parade, with Gordon Brown and Mr Osborne both up.

And this is while the Coalition tensions bite again. On Dispatches, Lib Dem Lord Oakeshott said "Clearly Mr Hunt should have resigned some time ago" - you can read our report here.

Vince Cable, however, seems to have gone in for some compromise. The FT reports  that he will pledge to make it easier to fire people today through 'compromise agreement' rather than the 'no fault dismissal' plans laid out in the Beecroft report.

OPEN DEBATE

And there's more bad news for George, the Times (£) has splashed on a poll showing that 80 per cent Brits want a referendum on Europe - with 50 per cent of those thinking it should happen straight away.

But is it good for us? In a surprising turn, the Guardian reports  that Open Europe - a Eurosceptic think tank - believes we should stay in the EU. An exit would pose "unpredictable political and economic risks.

And Tory MP  George Eustice agrees. In a piece for the Guardian, he argues that it's better to reform the EU from the inside.

BALLS POLL

Labour could be profiting from this news run today, but instead there are few embarrassing stories about them.

The Mail reports that the Shadow Chancellor ordered a survey - costing thousands of pounds - into whether or not people like him.

Labour party sources said the results found that Mr Balls is still seen as a turn-off by many, both politically and personally. The Mail on Sunday commissioned its own survey - and it showed that Mr Balls is seen as 'uninspiring, untrustworthy and unlikeable'. Oh dear.

MAKE BRADFORD LABOUR?

Ed Balls will be relieved that Ed Miliband also looks silly. The Guardian  reports that he visited Bradford on the Saturday to speak to those who switched from voting Labour to Respect.

He met with a group of Muslim women, one of whom had been on the TV show "Make Bradford British" - a much-criticised reality TV experiment that stoked racial tensions in the West Yorkshire city. He responded "Great!" He'd clearly not watched it.

MAY V JUDGES

Theresa May has clearly regained her mojo after the dates debacle - today's she's making a statement on immigration rules in the House at 3.30pm.  The Mail says she's "declared war on judges who refuse to deport foreign criminals because of their human rights" and  the Guardian says she's "ready for showdown".

They report that she would seek the backing of parliament to give priority to deportation above the right to family life enshrined in article 8 of the European convention on human rights.

LEAVING NANCY BEHIND

And finally, perhaps Dave should be 'chillaxing' more - the stress of the job is clearly getting to him. The Sun  has splashed on a story about how he left his daughter Nancy behind in a pub on the weekend.

An "insider" from the pub said: "You'd have thought someone would have done a headcount or something."

TWEETS AND TWITS

PPS Conor Burns tweets:

"@Conor_BurnsMP: Just having a drink with Lady T and going through the Sunday papers"

Wonder what she made of George's 'blame the eurozone' piece in yesterday's Telegraph?

POLL WATCH

Latest YouGov/Sunday Times: Conservatives 34%, Labour 42%, Lib Dems 7%, UKIP 9%

The Independent has splashed on a poll that shows

TOP COMMENT

In The Telegraph

Boris Johnson:  Hail Mayor Mike and the paper cups that will not runneth over

Andrew Gilligan: London Olympics 2012: get set for the gridlock games

Leader:Michael Gove is right: we must do better

Leader: The world is watching

Best of the rest

Alex Brummer in the Mail:  George Osborne can't blame Europe for all our problems

George Eustice in the Guardian: Britain can do better than leave the EU. We can change it

Mary Ann Sieghart in the Independent:  A referendum is coming. So why doesn't Cameron take the lead?

Ian Birrell in the Guardian:  The Tories are becoming the 'nasty party' on immigration

THE AGENDA

Today: Parliament returns from break.

Today: Annual conference of the GMB union. Brighton Centre.

10am: Gordon Brown and George Osborne at Leveson Inquiry. The Royal Courts of Justice, The Strand, London

2.30pm: Defence questions.

3.30pm: Theresa May makes a Commons statement on immigration. House of Commons.

Friday, 8 June 2012

Fraser Nelson on wefare dependency..

Lord Prescott represents the Old Labour wreckers, who always resented these private companies. Theirs was the lazy, less politically risky system of mass pauperism, of posting welfare cheques to edge-of-town housing estates while not asking many questions about the lives of the people inside them. This may have been excusable a generation ago, when a growing economy did tend to reduce the number of unemployed. But nowadays, when any growth simply sucks in more workers from overseas, unemployment is permanent. Tackling it is the toughest task in politics. Fraser Nelson on Labour's greatest moral failure - welfare dependency.




Brogan's brief..


WILL HE WON'T HE?

Today the papers are full of speculation on George Osborne's "hint" - or "threat" if you read the Guardian or the Independent - of an EU referendum.

On the Today programme yesterday he got everyone excited by saying:

"A reshaped relationship with Europe would imply, would involve, a transfer of sovereignty or powers to Brussels. I think we have a very clear safeguard in the system now, thanks to this Government, which is, if there is any transfer of power from this country, transfer of competence or transfer of sovereignty from this country to the European Union, then there will be a referendum."

It's not explicit, but it's certainly a hint. The Times (£) reports that this surprised Downing Street and the Lib Dems - and could cause tensions in the Coalition. Is this George the strategist at work, trying to outfox Labour's referendum chat?  

It's interesting that this happened while Dave was in Berlin talking about the eurozone crisis.  We've splashed on the robust stance he took, dismissing Angela Merkel's suggestion that the European Union should eventually have a single national identity as "nonsense".

He signalled that Britain was prepared to veto a new EU treaty unless it included safeguards for the City - and flatly refused a financial transactions tax.

Mrs Merkel hit back. She said "in a currency union have to move closer together", reinforcing the shift to "a multi-speed Europe" which had begun with the single currency. "We cannot just stop [the process] because one or other doesn't want to join in yet." You can read more on the specifics in the FT report here . The graphic breakdown of the situation in the Independent is also worth looking at.

They disagreed on the speed of reform too. He urged "immediate action", she called him "impatient". Our cartoon of them discussing the weather, before blowing away in the storm, probably sums things up.

Our leader column called it a "a watershed moment" and that there is a "a sense that we are moving towards something entirely new."

Dave and George best be careful though - the Mail won't tolerate a tease. In its leader column  today it demands "No more betrayals on the EU referendum."

And this diplomacy stuff could become farcical thanks to football.  The Sun splashes on the ministers who plan to boycott Euro 2012 over human rights violations in Ukraine - unless England get to the quarter-finals.

The Foreign Office said:  "No ministers will be attending group games at Euro 2012. We're keeping attendance at later stages under review in the light of ministers' schedules and concerns about selective justice and the law in Ukraine."  

They aren't the only ones fed up with politicking.  The Times (£) reports that Jeremy Heywood hopes to rein in the Coalition's 83 special advisers. He wants greater scrutiny and accountability from them post-Adam Smith. Whitehall sources are concerned that   "Many special advisers get a bunch of documents when they arrive and are broadly left to get on with it."

WORLD CRISIS

This is all to the backdrop of a worsening global financial crisis, of course. Yesterday Spain's credit rating was slashed from A to BBB by Fitch and China cut its interest rates - an acknowledgement that they're in trouble (you can read more in the FT's report here ).

The US and the Bank of England stood steady, but Ben Bernanke said that "the situation in Europe poses significant risks to the US financial system and economy and must be monitored closely."  

BRIDE AND JOY

Closer to home, the big announcement is the ban on forced marriages - it's becoming a specific criminal offence. Dave will say:  "Forced marriage is abhorrent and is little more than slavery. To force anyone into marriage against their will is simply wrong and that is why we have taken decisive action to make it illegal."

The Sun has claimed victory on this one:  "Govt backs Sun's war on cruel weddings", while the Mail  who splashed on it yesterday points out that the new law could mean we're going to rescue women who are smuggled abroad to be married. Somehow I'm not sure the half a million pound budget will stretch that far.

MILIBANDING

Meanwhile, Ed Miliband, ever at the centre of important world events, is talking about Englishness and the union. He's written in the Telegraph  today saying that we can forge a progressive patriotism based on the qualities that shone through during the Queen's Diamond Jubilee weekend. He admits that the Labour Party has not been very good at patriotism in recent years and that discussing Englishness might undermine the union.

During his speech yesterday he also admitted that he looks a bit like Wallace from Wallace and Gromit. The Sun has a wonderful graphic showing Ed's face slowly merging into Wallace's - it's worth keeping.

And finally, this English-Scottish issue might be one to keep an eye on.  The Independent reports that No 10 has got squeamish about cutting Scottish regiments.

POLL WATCH

Latest YouGov/The Sun results: Conservatives 34%, Labour 43%, Lib Dems 8%, UKIP 6%

Overall government approval rating: -35

TOP COMMENT

In The Telegraph 

Fraser Nelson: John Prescott climbed the ladder – now he wants to saw it away

Ed Miliband: The England I love is defined by its spirit

Leader: The comfortable course is no longer an option

Leader: Rights for grandparents

Best of the rest

Owen Jones in the Independent:  England, Miliband's England, is a lost country

William Rees-Mogg in the Times (£):   There's only one question on Europe: in or out

Gaby Hinsliff in the Guardian:  On pensioners, Iain Duncan Smith is right: 'granny bashing' is fair

Jin Liqun and Keyu Jin in the Financial Times (£):  Europe should stop arguing and look to Asia

THE AGENDA

Today: Theresa May will make an announcement on forced marriage

Today: Lord Freud, Parliamentary Under Secretary of State for Work and Pensions, will make an announcement on the benefits of Universal Credit for young people aged 25 years and below

Today: Eric Pickles, will set out new guidance for strategies to support local shops




Thursday, 7 June 2012

David Owen's vision for Europe

The economic crisis has presented us with clear choices for the future.
 
As a student I travelled extensively around Europe, particularly to Greece, France, West and East Germany and Czechoslovakia. I loved the diversity and depth of the different cultures. I was enchanted by the way people identified with their village, town or city and, in most cases, their nation. All of this seemed to come together under the term "European".
 
I was then, and still am today, proud to call myself a European. I am not a Eurosceptic in the way this term has been used for people hostile to Europe. But mine is a cultural identification. I never felt in the 1960s or now that Europe was or would ever become my country. Europeans are friends and neighbours, but not my fellow citizens.
 
The eurozone crisis now presents us with a clear choice: do we want to be part of a country called Europe? Or should the UK be a self-governing nation in a new, looser European Community?
 
Europe in crisis
 
There have been only two basic models for Europe as it moves through the crisis that began in 2009. The first is an arrangement long favoured by the UK but also an acceptable compromise to many other member states. It keeps to the present union of self-governing states with a separation of powers between the supranational — those passed from the nation state to a European body — and the intergovernmental — those remaining within the nation state.
 
The second model is to develop a fiscal union within the eurozone, more and more explicitly championed as the desirable long-term development by Germany, the EU's most powerful state. This model offers a legislature in which the European Parliament would embody the lower chamber and the EU Council of Ministers the upper. The President of the European Commission and the President of the Council would be elected. The Commission would be an executive and virtually a European government, with federal authority for trade, economic, industrial, social, justice, environmental, agricultural, fishing, foreign and defence policies. The European Central Bank would replace the need for national banks, though they might remain as symbols. Under a fiscal union the explicit expectation would be that all EU member states would eventually join the eurozone.
 
Redrawing Europe
 
The EU is reaching the point where it cannot continue to be ambivalent about these two models. In the UK, but also in some other countries, there are growing public demands for a principled and consistent position to resist any further merging of the two, because the people in these countries want to remain self-governing. Yet these same countries see the argument for greater integration within the eurozone to help to resolve its continued crisis. The solution is to enable those countries within the eurozone who wish to integrate further to do so and to allow those countries who do not ever envisage becoming part of the eurozone to remain in a restructured single market.
 
For this to happen without long and tortured arguments, challenges to the legal interpretation of European treaties and allegations of bad faith, all member countries must be involved as equals in a restructuring of the EU.
 
The European Community
 
All countries should remain full members of a single market, which would form the basis of a larger, separate organisation. It should continue to operate under qualified majority voting based on a revitalised single market, and would hopefully include Turkey as a full participating member, as well as other members of the European Economic Area. Such a grouping of 32 or more states could be called the European Community, funded and controlled by its member states. It would have common international environmental policies and could use the old political co-operation mechanism to co-ordinate foreign and security policies, with Nato membership enjoyed by most of its constituents. The EU would continue to lead in devising legislation for the wider single market but not as the ultimate authority.
 
The European Union
 
What will also emerge as part of this restructuring is a eurozone in which economic, fiscal and monetary policies, taken with the Lisbon treaty arrangements for foreign and security policy, will develop in ways that involve, to all intents and purposes, though not in name, a single government. This will probably be acceptable for most, but not all of the existing eurozone countries and potentially for others who intend to become members of the eurozone. Such a grouping would continue to be called the European Union.
 
Some of the countries, particularly Germany, want further economic integration beyond the fiscal compact agreed in December 2011. The German Chancellor, Angela Merkel, made it clear to her party, the Christian Democratic Union, this year that she saw Europe as a "community of destiny" and she will ask for a mandate to achieve that from German voters in the autumn election of 2013. The present opposition party, the Social Democratic Party, shares much of her vision.
There will be resistance to the German design of a fiscal union from France, but François Hollande, the President, is likely to choose to continue the Franco-German project to make a success of their single currency. With a reinvigorated political Right, Mr Hollande might have difficulty in winning a referendum in France. But even if he lost, Germany would not let the euro fall and return to the deutschmark. It would assemble a small group to keep the euro intact and expect, at some later date, that the number of eurozone countries would increase.
 
The debtor problem
 
Greece, Portugal, Ireland, Italy and Spain, inside the eurozone but with mounting economic difficulties, may find public criticism of austerity too strong to withstand. The public may demand more and more measures for growth and in the process become resigned to leaving the eurozone. What is not clear is whether, if they leave, these countries will be able to stay in the EU, hoping to rejoin the eurozone; if they are not welcome, they will be fully entitled to be members of the single market and European Community.
 
The referendum
 
In the UK, by the general election of 2015, unless the Conservative Party and the Labour Party change the situation over Europe, the UK Independence Party may grow in strength as it develops a wider agenda against crime and immigration in response to feelings that the British are being pushed around by eurozone integration. At the very least UKIP will be the lever for forcing a Conservative government to concede a referendum on Europe. Labour will be forced to concede as well. But a referendum will be lost in the UK if the only option is ever greater integration within the EU. It will be won only if the present Europe is restructured and the choices in a referendum are more attractive.
 
A referendum on the future of Europe I believe is inevitable at some point between 2013 and 2106 at the latest. I would hope such a referendum would pose something like the following choice:
 
• Do you want the UK to be part of the single market in a wider European Community? Yes/No Do you want the UK to remain in the European Union, keeping open the option of joining the more integrated eurozone? Yes/No The first question would be very likely to be answered by the British public with a "yes", and any British government would urge them to do so. The second question would be harder to predict, but it would be a genuine choice, and the government might be neutral, ready to follow rather than lead public opinion. If both questions were answered "no", this would in effect mean a total withdrawal.
 
Conclusion
 
In Europe Restructured? I have drawn on my 50 years of involvement with Europe's development to trace a path to resolve the present crisis. It is bound to suffer from being only one UK politician's perspective, but at least it comes from someone who still has a full-hearted commitment to achieving greater European unity, but also one who has long argued that the eurozone design is fatally flawed.
 
I have long believed that in the UK there must be limits set to the process of European integration. On issues that go to the heart of British democracy, people want to feel that they can influence their own destiny. European decision-making evokes so many doubts and questions in people's minds because they cannot identify with so much of what it encompasses.
 
The British public do not like to feel they are being pushed around. We are loyal members of clubs, but not afraid to restructure a club to suit different circumstances. We are not afraid of change. We have no deep-rooted dislike of foreigners; we are content to live in a multiracial Britain. We are neither jingoistic nor chauvinistic.
 
We just want our politicians to uphold our right to democratic self- government in this country.
 
These are attitudes that we believe in, attitudes that go back to Magna Carta. People want to be able to influence the nature of the society in which they live, the levels of taxation, benefits and pensions, the level of unemployment, the amount of redistribution or the amount of their earnings that they can keep to spend as they wish. These choices are the bedrock of a democracy.
 
David Owen
 

David Owen's European vision..

This graphic from the Times nicely illustrates David Owen's European vision..