Thursday, 7 June 2012
Morning brief..
George Osborne has just been on the Today programme. He said:
On further EU integration to save the euro: “Let me be absolutely clear, Britain is not going to be part of that banking union.”
But “It’s massively in Britain’s interest for the euro to survive”
On the opportunity to renegotiate Britain's relations with Europe: “We have a safeguard in the system. If there is a transfer of power.. then there will be a referendum.”
On the U-turns: “They made up less than 5 per cent of the budget..It was much better to say ‘look we won’t do it’ ... The government needs to be focused on [the big questions].. not on the battles that don’t matter”
On the budget-making process: “I don’t think the way bits of the budget were leaked was helpful.”
Cameron leaves Oslo with the Norwegian PM today and together they head to Berlin where he will chat to Angela Merkel about the eurozone crisis. At 12.30pm they will be answering questions from a group of students (you can watch the live stream here - he’ll be speaking just after the Bank of England’s interest rates decision).
What will Cam say to Mrs Merkel? Some of his MPs have a suggestion: The Fresh Start group, which has been studying our relationship with the EU for intelligent ways of reordering it, tells him crisis brings opportunity.
In the Telegraph, Andrea Leadsom , its chairman, has written that this is the moment to extract agreement for a renegotiation. No doubt we all wish Mr Cameron would do the truth unto power/emperor's new clothes thing by confronting Mrs Merkel with some plain truths about the euro. But how does he game it: what does he have to offer? Will he trade cash help with the crisis for a deal on renegotiation? What if there's an exit fee?
EURO CRISIS COMMENT
The Telegraph leader column suggests:
“He should make clear to Mrs Merkel that the price of UK support for any new treaty would be a guaranteed renegotiation of this country’s position within what would be a fundamentally different Europe from the one we joined – with the outcome put to a referendum.”
Peter Oborne takes a similarly robust stance, saying:
“The last time Europe was in the grip of a rigid financial dogma was in the immediate aftermath of the First World War, when the collective bureaucratic and political mind was unable to envisage an alternative to the prevailing gold standard.
This outdated economic thinking inflicted devastation and untold suffering, while sowing the seeds for the rise of fascism and the outbreak of the Second World War. It is not going too far to observe that the chanceries of Europe are in the grip of a similar madness today.”
The former Labour Foreign Secretary David Owen is equally disillusioned with the current dogma. He offers a plan for the reorganisation of Europe in the Times (£) . He suggests that all countries should remain full members of a single market, but the eurozone countries that wish to remain part of the euro integrate further.
He also says:
“A referendum on the future of Europe I believe is inevitable at some point between 2013 and 2106 at the latest. I would hope such a referendum would pose something like the following choice:
Do you want the UK to be part of the single market in a wider European Community? Yes/No Do you want the UK to remain in the European Union, keeping open the option of joining the more integrated eurozone?”
As you would expect from the good Dr, it's very clever, but I must admit I found the questions a bit opaque.
SPANISH DRAMA
And of course, this is all to the backdrop of the growing crisis in Spain. The Guardian leads with “Save our banks or break euro, Spain tells EU” and the FT’s “Europe weighs Spain bank rescue” says it all really.
Alex Brummer in the Mail brings the point home:
“And it is the Spanish government’s hopeless efforts to deal with an enveloping banking catastrophe that has brought the whole euro experiment and, for that matter, the prosperity of the world to the precipice...the leaders in the euro area are now in a desperate race against the clock.”
MILIBAND ON SCOTLAND
Always at the centre of things, Ed Miliband is focusing on Britain. At 11am he’s making a speech on Scottish independence. He is expected to say:
"We in the Labour Party have been too reluctant to talk about England in recent years. We've concentrated on shaping a new politics for Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland. But some people in England felt Labour's attention had turned away. That something was holding us back from celebrating England too. That we were too nervous to talk of English pride and English character. Connecting it to the kind of nationalism that left us ill at ease.
"There may be a temptation on the part of others to conjure a view of Englishness which does not represent our nation, a mirror image of the worst aspects of Scottish nationalism - hostile to outsiders, anti-Scottish, England somehow cut off from the rest of Britain, cut off from the outside world, fearful what is beyond our borders, our best days behind us.”
"I don't think like that. I love the nation that we have."
The Independent has a poll proving his point (well, at least in the case of England and Wales). Only three in 10 people in England and Wales want to see Scotland break away from the United Kingdom.
ANOTHER WARSI PROBE
And the Warsi debacle rumbles on. She’s facing another investigation by the House of Lords standards committee.
Matthew Parris in the Times and Steve Richards in the Independent are united in the view that Lady Warsi is under attack because of the nature of the Chairman’s role.
Mr Parris calls it “an awful job: nobody really knows what you’re for,” while Mr Richards says she is “more dispensable” than many of her colleagues.
RICH BENEFITS
Meanwhile, the pressure’s on to cut rich people’s benefits. The Guardian reports that Nick Clegg has joined the fight, telling his colleagues he’d be happy to see them dramatically cut.
A party spokesperson said: "If you're faced with a choice in terms of helping the wealthiest pensioners or helping the vulnerable across Britain, then his priority is the vulnerable people across the country who need the most help.”
More information is available in our report here.
CLEGG THE NOVELIST
And they say everyone has a novel in them. Nick Clegg is no exception. In an interview in Easy Living magazine, he said he tried to write one in his 20s, producing 120 pages, before giving up. He said: “it was shockingly bad and will never see the light of day.” He also lets us know his favourite books are Disgrace by J M Coetzee and The Tiger Who Came to Tea by Judith Kerr. (You can read more in our report here).
Our leader column presents a “draft” of Mr Clegg’s work. It begins: “For a man of his age, 45, he has, to his mind, solved the problem of politics rather well. Punctually, at 2pm, he presses the buzzer...”
PREZZA PRESSED
Nick isn’t the only one being poked fun at today. The Mail has interviewed one of the Jubilee “slave” stewards saying he had a marvellous time.
And by the way, if you were wondering why Gordon Brown missed the Jubilee, Ephraim Hardcastle has this:
“Gordon Brown was invited to the St Paul’s service of thanksgiving for the Queen’s six decades on the throne, but the former premier pleaded a prior engagement – the third marriage of former Labour MP Henry McLeish, 63, to Caryn Nicolson, 48. A spokesman said the Browns ‘found it impossible to manage their travel engagements to attend both events’.”
FORCING OUT FORCED MARRIAGE
And finally it’s worth noting the Mail’s front page: “Forced marriage to be outlawed: Parents face jail for coercing daughters to wed against their will, which PM says is 'little more than slavery”
Theresa May will outline the plans tomorrow.
POLL WATCH
Latest YouGov/The Sun results: Conservatives 34%, Labour 43%, Lib Dems 8%, UKIP 7%
Overall government approval rating: -36
TODAY'S COMMENT
Peter Oborne in the Telegraph: The euro’s 'guilty men’ are now steering Europe to catastrophe
Sue Cameron in the Telegraph: Londoners won’t take kindly to Zil lanes at the Olympics
Andrea Leadsom: The eurozone crisis is a 'perfect opportunity' for Britain
Zoe Williams in the Guardian: The jubilee jobseekers show modern Britain at its worst
Steve Richards in the Independent: Warsi's problem is that her job just doesn't matter enough
David Owen in the Times (£): My vision for a new Europe
David Aaronovitch in the Times (£): You shouldn’t need a beard to bless a Queen
Leader in the Telegraph: Cameron must name his price for on EU deal
TODAY'S AGENDA
Today: 'Park Lane' - a new novel from George Osborne's wife is published
9am: Philip Hammond, Chief of General Staff Gen Sir Peter Wall and US Chief of Staff Gen Raymond Odierno speeches to Rusi. Church House, Deans Yard, London
11am: Ed Miliband gives a speech on"Defending the Union in England". Weston Roof Pavilion, Royal Festival Hall
12pm: David Cameron, Angela Merkel and Norwegian PM Jens Stoltenberg attend an event in Berlin with around 100 students to discuss the subject 'Learning from each other. New approach to the relationship between citizen and state'
12pm: Bank of England's Monetary Policy Committee announces its latest interest rate decision
12pm: Alex Salmond at Scottish First Minister's Questions
10.30pm: BBC Question Time
On further EU integration to save the euro: “Let me be absolutely clear, Britain is not going to be part of that banking union.”
But “It’s massively in Britain’s interest for the euro to survive”
On the opportunity to renegotiate Britain's relations with Europe: “We have a safeguard in the system. If there is a transfer of power.. then there will be a referendum.”
On the U-turns: “They made up less than 5 per cent of the budget..It was much better to say ‘look we won’t do it’ ... The government needs to be focused on [the big questions].. not on the battles that don’t matter”
On the budget-making process: “I don’t think the way bits of the budget were leaked was helpful.”
Cameron leaves Oslo with the Norwegian PM today and together they head to Berlin where he will chat to Angela Merkel about the eurozone crisis. At 12.30pm they will be answering questions from a group of students (you can watch the live stream here - he’ll be speaking just after the Bank of England’s interest rates decision).
What will Cam say to Mrs Merkel? Some of his MPs have a suggestion: The Fresh Start group, which has been studying our relationship with the EU for intelligent ways of reordering it, tells him crisis brings opportunity.
In the Telegraph, Andrea Leadsom , its chairman, has written that this is the moment to extract agreement for a renegotiation. No doubt we all wish Mr Cameron would do the truth unto power/emperor's new clothes thing by confronting Mrs Merkel with some plain truths about the euro. But how does he game it: what does he have to offer? Will he trade cash help with the crisis for a deal on renegotiation? What if there's an exit fee?
EURO CRISIS COMMENT
The Telegraph leader column suggests:
“He should make clear to Mrs Merkel that the price of UK support for any new treaty would be a guaranteed renegotiation of this country’s position within what would be a fundamentally different Europe from the one we joined – with the outcome put to a referendum.”
Peter Oborne takes a similarly robust stance, saying:
“The last time Europe was in the grip of a rigid financial dogma was in the immediate aftermath of the First World War, when the collective bureaucratic and political mind was unable to envisage an alternative to the prevailing gold standard.
This outdated economic thinking inflicted devastation and untold suffering, while sowing the seeds for the rise of fascism and the outbreak of the Second World War. It is not going too far to observe that the chanceries of Europe are in the grip of a similar madness today.”
The former Labour Foreign Secretary David Owen is equally disillusioned with the current dogma. He offers a plan for the reorganisation of Europe in the Times (£) . He suggests that all countries should remain full members of a single market, but the eurozone countries that wish to remain part of the euro integrate further.
He also says:
“A referendum on the future of Europe I believe is inevitable at some point between 2013 and 2106 at the latest. I would hope such a referendum would pose something like the following choice:
Do you want the UK to be part of the single market in a wider European Community? Yes/No Do you want the UK to remain in the European Union, keeping open the option of joining the more integrated eurozone?”
As you would expect from the good Dr, it's very clever, but I must admit I found the questions a bit opaque.
SPANISH DRAMA
And of course, this is all to the backdrop of the growing crisis in Spain. The Guardian leads with “Save our banks or break euro, Spain tells EU” and the FT’s “Europe weighs Spain bank rescue” says it all really.
Alex Brummer in the Mail brings the point home:
“And it is the Spanish government’s hopeless efforts to deal with an enveloping banking catastrophe that has brought the whole euro experiment and, for that matter, the prosperity of the world to the precipice...the leaders in the euro area are now in a desperate race against the clock.”
MILIBAND ON SCOTLAND
Always at the centre of things, Ed Miliband is focusing on Britain. At 11am he’s making a speech on Scottish independence. He is expected to say:
"We in the Labour Party have been too reluctant to talk about England in recent years. We've concentrated on shaping a new politics for Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland. But some people in England felt Labour's attention had turned away. That something was holding us back from celebrating England too. That we were too nervous to talk of English pride and English character. Connecting it to the kind of nationalism that left us ill at ease.
"There may be a temptation on the part of others to conjure a view of Englishness which does not represent our nation, a mirror image of the worst aspects of Scottish nationalism - hostile to outsiders, anti-Scottish, England somehow cut off from the rest of Britain, cut off from the outside world, fearful what is beyond our borders, our best days behind us.”
"I don't think like that. I love the nation that we have."
The Independent has a poll proving his point (well, at least in the case of England and Wales). Only three in 10 people in England and Wales want to see Scotland break away from the United Kingdom.
ANOTHER WARSI PROBE
And the Warsi debacle rumbles on. She’s facing another investigation by the House of Lords standards committee.
Matthew Parris in the Times and Steve Richards in the Independent are united in the view that Lady Warsi is under attack because of the nature of the Chairman’s role.
Mr Parris calls it “an awful job: nobody really knows what you’re for,” while Mr Richards says she is “more dispensable” than many of her colleagues.
RICH BENEFITS
Meanwhile, the pressure’s on to cut rich people’s benefits. The Guardian reports that Nick Clegg has joined the fight, telling his colleagues he’d be happy to see them dramatically cut.
A party spokesperson said: "If you're faced with a choice in terms of helping the wealthiest pensioners or helping the vulnerable across Britain, then his priority is the vulnerable people across the country who need the most help.”
More information is available in our report here.
CLEGG THE NOVELIST
And they say everyone has a novel in them. Nick Clegg is no exception. In an interview in Easy Living magazine, he said he tried to write one in his 20s, producing 120 pages, before giving up. He said: “it was shockingly bad and will never see the light of day.” He also lets us know his favourite books are Disgrace by J M Coetzee and The Tiger Who Came to Tea by Judith Kerr. (You can read more in our report here).
Our leader column presents a “draft” of Mr Clegg’s work. It begins: “For a man of his age, 45, he has, to his mind, solved the problem of politics rather well. Punctually, at 2pm, he presses the buzzer...”
PREZZA PRESSED
Nick isn’t the only one being poked fun at today. The Mail has interviewed one of the Jubilee “slave” stewards saying he had a marvellous time.
And by the way, if you were wondering why Gordon Brown missed the Jubilee, Ephraim Hardcastle has this:
“Gordon Brown was invited to the St Paul’s service of thanksgiving for the Queen’s six decades on the throne, but the former premier pleaded a prior engagement – the third marriage of former Labour MP Henry McLeish, 63, to Caryn Nicolson, 48. A spokesman said the Browns ‘found it impossible to manage their travel engagements to attend both events’.”
FORCING OUT FORCED MARRIAGE
And finally it’s worth noting the Mail’s front page: “Forced marriage to be outlawed: Parents face jail for coercing daughters to wed against their will, which PM says is 'little more than slavery”
Theresa May will outline the plans tomorrow.
POLL WATCH
Latest YouGov/The Sun results: Conservatives 34%, Labour 43%, Lib Dems 8%, UKIP 7%
Overall government approval rating: -36
TODAY'S COMMENT
Peter Oborne in the Telegraph: The euro’s 'guilty men’ are now steering Europe to catastrophe
Sue Cameron in the Telegraph: Londoners won’t take kindly to Zil lanes at the Olympics
Andrea Leadsom: The eurozone crisis is a 'perfect opportunity' for Britain
Zoe Williams in the Guardian: The jubilee jobseekers show modern Britain at its worst
Steve Richards in the Independent: Warsi's problem is that her job just doesn't matter enough
David Owen in the Times (£): My vision for a new Europe
David Aaronovitch in the Times (£): You shouldn’t need a beard to bless a Queen
Leader in the Telegraph: Cameron must name his price for on EU deal
TODAY'S AGENDA
Today: 'Park Lane' - a new novel from George Osborne's wife is published
9am: Philip Hammond, Chief of General Staff Gen Sir Peter Wall and US Chief of Staff Gen Raymond Odierno speeches to Rusi. Church House, Deans Yard, London
11am: Ed Miliband gives a speech on"Defending the Union in England". Weston Roof Pavilion, Royal Festival Hall
12pm: David Cameron, Angela Merkel and Norwegian PM Jens Stoltenberg attend an event in Berlin with around 100 students to discuss the subject 'Learning from each other. New approach to the relationship between citizen and state'
12pm: Bank of England's Monetary Policy Committee announces its latest interest rate decision
12pm: Alex Salmond at Scottish First Minister's Questions
10.30pm: BBC Question Time
Wednesday, 6 June 2012
Ben Brogan's morning roundup..
Parliament might be in recess and politics put aside for the Jubilee, but the eurozone crisis still rages across the continent, giving David Cameron something to be busy with.
Yesterday he had a telephone call with Barack Obama about preparations for this month's G20 summit in Mexico. No wonder - things are getting hairy. Yesterday Spain admitted for the first time that it can no longer raise money on the global markets or roll over its sovereign bonds.
And manufacturing and jobs data in the US and China came in weaker than expected. You can read more in Ambrose Evans-Pritchard's report.
Meanwhile, George Osborne had his own teleconference with G7 finance ministers on the euro crisis. The Mail reports that a deeper eurozone fiscal union was called for - edging us ever closer to a European superstate, it says.
Of course, the Tory party is giving George a hand. In a paper for the Centre for Policy Studies think-tank, the chairman of the Treasury Select Committee, Andrew Tyrie, has called on the IMF to develop contingency plans for Greece to leave the eurozone. He told the FT (£):
"To paraphrase Wilde . . . to be caught out by the collapse of Lehman might be construed as a misfortune. Not to be prepared for a Greek exit would be carelessness."
Dave is due to visit Berlin later this week, where he is expected to urge Angela Merkel for tougher fiscal governance in the eurozone. His challenge is to avoid appearing impotent, a bit player on the sidelines.
EURO CHAOS
Mr Osborne should also take note of Bruno Wakefield's feature in today's Telegraph. He warns that despite the "Yes" vote on the EU fiscal pact and some encouraging signals in the economy, we should be careful not to make Ireland an austerity pin-up. The positive picture masks some serious economic challenges - high unemployment, weaker economic activity than anticipated and eurozone contagion, of course.
In a column for today's Telegraph, Daniel Hannan argues that Eurocrats are treating the tumour instead of the patient. They see the survival of the euro as more important than the prosperity of the people using it.
Whereas Ambrose Evans-Pritchard argues that the Germans aren't really doing anything at all, saying: "Almost everything Angela Merkel is talking about already exists. She has dressed up an old arrangement as if it were new." They've firmly said no to any possibility of debt pooling so far.
WHAT A BAROMESS
And closer to home, David Cameron has a new mess in the making. He's decided that, unlike Jeremy Hunt, Baroness Warsi should be referred to the standards watchdog. He claimed that her dealings with her business associate were "very different" from Mr Hunt's conduct on Marr.
This is, of course, despite the fact that Sir Alistair Graham, the former chairman of the Committee on Standards in Public Life, said otherwise:
"The case is very strong. If there is found to be no substance to the allegation then that is fine, but at least people will have seen that in an important case that due process has been observed."
James Kirkup has the details. The FT (£) has some great analysis, pointing out that she's faced growing criticism in recent weeks from Tory Right-wingers who believe she is not tough enough or visible enough in defending the party.
In the Guardian, Ken Clarke is offering his own view, accusing the press of acting like a "lynch mob" towards Mr Hunt and Lady Warsi.
In a column in today's Telegraph, Conservative Home's Paul Goodman argues that Mr Cameron created Lady Warsi, put her in a difficult position by confining her to immigration control and integration policy, and may now be forced to destroy her. He explains:
"the architect of this mess isn't so much Lady Warsi as David Cameron. There is a terrible circularity in the story of their relationship. Her original appointment protected the Conservative Party from accusations of racism. However unfairly, her plight exposes the Prime Minister to precisely that charge. In 2007, Mr Cameron rushed into the politics of ethnicity to get his party out of a tight spot. He may now have the opportunity to repent at leisure."
Paul Goodman isn't the first to hint at the race point. James Macintyre in Guardian does too.
Dave might be reluctant to sack her though. The Mail's Ephraim Hardcastle column quotes a Tory source, saying: " Warsi is something of a loose cannon which is part of her appeal but makes her a dangerous enemy. She won't go as quietly as Jeremy Hunt. 'Don't mess with the Baroness' is what her colleagues say"
There are some great cartoons on the topic, check out Brookes in Times.
PREZZING MATTER
John Prescott has just been on the Today programme calling for an inquiry into a security firm's use of unpaid jobseekers to steward the Queen's diamond jubilee celebrations in London. The full report is available in the Guardian. He said:
"This government is exploiting this for cheap labour. Is this the standard going to be used for the Olympics"
GOING FOR GROWTH BONDS
Unlike every other paper, the Independent hasn't splashed on the Jubilee. Instead they report that the Chancellor has told Treasury officials to find ways to persuade savers to transfer billions of pounds held in bank accounts, building societies and investment funds to new government "growth bonds".
The money would be invested in infrastructure projects such as toll roads, green energy and housebuilding. Savers could be offered tax breaks, similar to those available in ISAs.
RICH BENEFITS
And the Sun has a little political surprise too. It reports that Iain Duncan Smith has picked a fight with Dave on pensioner benefits, claiming that the two are "at war" over the issue.
IDS wants £5 billion cut from OAP benefits, but that would break Dave's election promise to leave the giveaways untouched - No 10 have said no.
TWEETS AND TWITS
"@edballsmp: Standing room only at our Morley Diamond Jubilee lunch - turns out I am a dab hand with a big teapot http://mypict.me/n4GQy"
Now that's not fair on Ed Miliband.
TOP COMMENT
In The Telegraph
Paul Goodman: Cameron created Warsi – will he be forced to destroy her?
Daniel Hannan: The euro now equals poverty and deflation
Harry Mount: This great Jubilee had a missing ingredient
Leader: It is we who should be humble, Ma'am
Best of the rest
Simon Jenkins in the Guardian: A royal jubilee of bread and circuses, maybe, but the country needed it
Martin Sorrell in the Financial Times: Mea culpa – I act like the owner I am
Matthew Norman in the Independent: After 60 years, at last the country seems at ease with itself
Alex Brummer in the Daily Mail: Not such diamond years: How the Queen's reign has witnessed the decline of British industry
THE AGENDA
Today: David Cameron talks with Norwegian prime minister Jens Stoltenberg in Oslo
11am: The EU announces second estimate figures for GDP for the first quarter of 2012, following last month's flash estimate figures, Q1
Yesterday he had a telephone call with Barack Obama about preparations for this month's G20 summit in Mexico. No wonder - things are getting hairy. Yesterday Spain admitted for the first time that it can no longer raise money on the global markets or roll over its sovereign bonds.
And manufacturing and jobs data in the US and China came in weaker than expected. You can read more in Ambrose Evans-Pritchard's report.
Meanwhile, George Osborne had his own teleconference with G7 finance ministers on the euro crisis. The Mail reports that a deeper eurozone fiscal union was called for - edging us ever closer to a European superstate, it says.
Of course, the Tory party is giving George a hand. In a paper for the Centre for Policy Studies think-tank, the chairman of the Treasury Select Committee, Andrew Tyrie, has called on the IMF to develop contingency plans for Greece to leave the eurozone. He told the FT (£):
"To paraphrase Wilde . . . to be caught out by the collapse of Lehman might be construed as a misfortune. Not to be prepared for a Greek exit would be carelessness."
Dave is due to visit Berlin later this week, where he is expected to urge Angela Merkel for tougher fiscal governance in the eurozone. His challenge is to avoid appearing impotent, a bit player on the sidelines.
EURO CHAOS
Mr Osborne should also take note of Bruno Wakefield's feature in today's Telegraph. He warns that despite the "Yes" vote on the EU fiscal pact and some encouraging signals in the economy, we should be careful not to make Ireland an austerity pin-up. The positive picture masks some serious economic challenges - high unemployment, weaker economic activity than anticipated and eurozone contagion, of course.
In a column for today's Telegraph, Daniel Hannan argues that Eurocrats are treating the tumour instead of the patient. They see the survival of the euro as more important than the prosperity of the people using it.
Whereas Ambrose Evans-Pritchard argues that the Germans aren't really doing anything at all, saying: "Almost everything Angela Merkel is talking about already exists. She has dressed up an old arrangement as if it were new." They've firmly said no to any possibility of debt pooling so far.
WHAT A BAROMESS
And closer to home, David Cameron has a new mess in the making. He's decided that, unlike Jeremy Hunt, Baroness Warsi should be referred to the standards watchdog. He claimed that her dealings with her business associate were "very different" from Mr Hunt's conduct on Marr.
This is, of course, despite the fact that Sir Alistair Graham, the former chairman of the Committee on Standards in Public Life, said otherwise:
"The case is very strong. If there is found to be no substance to the allegation then that is fine, but at least people will have seen that in an important case that due process has been observed."
James Kirkup has the details. The FT (£) has some great analysis, pointing out that she's faced growing criticism in recent weeks from Tory Right-wingers who believe she is not tough enough or visible enough in defending the party.
In the Guardian, Ken Clarke is offering his own view, accusing the press of acting like a "lynch mob" towards Mr Hunt and Lady Warsi.
In a column in today's Telegraph, Conservative Home's Paul Goodman argues that Mr Cameron created Lady Warsi, put her in a difficult position by confining her to immigration control and integration policy, and may now be forced to destroy her. He explains:
"the architect of this mess isn't so much Lady Warsi as David Cameron. There is a terrible circularity in the story of their relationship. Her original appointment protected the Conservative Party from accusations of racism. However unfairly, her plight exposes the Prime Minister to precisely that charge. In 2007, Mr Cameron rushed into the politics of ethnicity to get his party out of a tight spot. He may now have the opportunity to repent at leisure."
Paul Goodman isn't the first to hint at the race point. James Macintyre in Guardian does too.
Dave might be reluctant to sack her though. The Mail's Ephraim Hardcastle column quotes a Tory source, saying: " Warsi is something of a loose cannon which is part of her appeal but makes her a dangerous enemy. She won't go as quietly as Jeremy Hunt. 'Don't mess with the Baroness' is what her colleagues say"
There are some great cartoons on the topic, check out Brookes in Times.
PREZZING MATTER
John Prescott has just been on the Today programme calling for an inquiry into a security firm's use of unpaid jobseekers to steward the Queen's diamond jubilee celebrations in London. The full report is available in the Guardian. He said:
"This government is exploiting this for cheap labour. Is this the standard going to be used for the Olympics"
GOING FOR GROWTH BONDS
Unlike every other paper, the Independent hasn't splashed on the Jubilee. Instead they report that the Chancellor has told Treasury officials to find ways to persuade savers to transfer billions of pounds held in bank accounts, building societies and investment funds to new government "growth bonds".
The money would be invested in infrastructure projects such as toll roads, green energy and housebuilding. Savers could be offered tax breaks, similar to those available in ISAs.
RICH BENEFITS
And the Sun has a little political surprise too. It reports that Iain Duncan Smith has picked a fight with Dave on pensioner benefits, claiming that the two are "at war" over the issue.
IDS wants £5 billion cut from OAP benefits, but that would break Dave's election promise to leave the giveaways untouched - No 10 have said no.
TWEETS AND TWITS
"@edballsmp: Standing room only at our Morley Diamond Jubilee lunch - turns out I am a dab hand with a big teapot http://mypict.me/n4GQy"
Now that's not fair on Ed Miliband.
TOP COMMENT
In The Telegraph
Paul Goodman: Cameron created Warsi – will he be forced to destroy her?
Daniel Hannan: The euro now equals poverty and deflation
Harry Mount: This great Jubilee had a missing ingredient
Leader: It is we who should be humble, Ma'am
Best of the rest
Simon Jenkins in the Guardian: A royal jubilee of bread and circuses, maybe, but the country needed it
Martin Sorrell in the Financial Times: Mea culpa – I act like the owner I am
Matthew Norman in the Independent: After 60 years, at last the country seems at ease with itself
Alex Brummer in the Daily Mail: Not such diamond years: How the Queen's reign has witnessed the decline of British industry
THE AGENDA
Today: David Cameron talks with Norwegian prime minister Jens Stoltenberg in Oslo
11am: The EU announces second estimate figures for GDP for the first quarter of 2012, following last month's flash estimate figures, Q1
Tuesday, 5 June 2012
GP's need to get real..
'Doctors feel betrayed that a pension contract that they signed up to can be ripped up so readily. But doctors did particularly well out of Labour, with the BMA negotiating handsome new contracts for GPs and consultants that bolstered final salary pensions. Much of that extra income is now being clawed back but doctors will not starve' - Phil Hammond GP in today's Times.
What an understatement. Dr Meldrum and his BMA colleagues need to get real. Labour's ridiculous pension contract was part of that profligate boom mentality that got us into this mess. The world has moved on. But not apparently the BMA..
What an understatement. Dr Meldrum and his BMA colleagues need to get real. Labour's ridiculous pension contract was part of that profligate boom mentality that got us into this mess. The world has moved on. But not apparently the BMA..
Monday, 4 June 2012
Soros on eurozone..
Germany is likely to do what is necessary to preserve the euro – but nothing more. That would result in a eurozone dominated by Germany in which the divergence between the creditor and debtor countries would continue to widen and the periphery would turn into permanently depressed areas in need of constant transfer of payments. That would turn the European Union into something very different from what it was when it was a “fantastic object” that fired peoples imagination. It would be a German empire with the periphery as the hinterland writes George Soros in an analysis of the eurozone well worth reading..
Tuesday, 29 May 2012
Politicians have an terrible record..
Almost ubiquitously with any commentary on politicians or politics is the suggestion that our political class are widely distrusted and held in contempt by those they govern. In the context of Westminster, this is often related back to the MPs expenses scandal under the last Labour government - not to mention honours for cash, former ministers posing as 'cabs for hire' or Lords offering to amend legislation to the highest bidder. Each of course took their toll, and certainly provided us with one of the worst parliament's & Speaker - now Baron Martin of Springburn - in our history.
But it goes a lot deeper than that. It seems to me that our political class - with a few honourable exceptions - have been wrong on almost all of the major economic and social issues of the last decade. Moreover, in every case, and presumably because it would not have been given, they failed to either consult or gain the consent of the British people. Here are just five.
1. Multi-culturalism, the widely discredited notion that lead directly to the 7/7 bombings by domestically radicalised terrorists..
2. An open-door immigration policy - designed to 'rub the right's nose in it' - which has irrevocably changed British society whilst denying some of the most vulnerable of our citizens a working future..
3. Welfare dependency, whose numbingly anti-aspirational lifestyle-choice has destroyed the future of hundreds of thousands across vast swaths of British cities..
4. The 2007 banking crash, which no politician forecast, have yet to provide an apology for or indeed a solution to..
5. The disastrous euro which, despite claims to the contrary, Labour continued to support throughout its 13 years in government. The question was only when we would join, not if. Right up until May 2010, Labour continued to fund a specialist treasury department whose purpose was to prepare the country for entry. It was finally disbanded in George Osborne's first budget..
Is it any wonder people do not trust politicians?
But it goes a lot deeper than that. It seems to me that our political class - with a few honourable exceptions - have been wrong on almost all of the major economic and social issues of the last decade. Moreover, in every case, and presumably because it would not have been given, they failed to either consult or gain the consent of the British people. Here are just five.
1. Multi-culturalism, the widely discredited notion that lead directly to the 7/7 bombings by domestically radicalised terrorists..
2. An open-door immigration policy - designed to 'rub the right's nose in it' - which has irrevocably changed British society whilst denying some of the most vulnerable of our citizens a working future..
3. Welfare dependency, whose numbingly anti-aspirational lifestyle-choice has destroyed the future of hundreds of thousands across vast swaths of British cities..
4. The 2007 banking crash, which no politician forecast, have yet to provide an apology for or indeed a solution to..
5. The disastrous euro which, despite claims to the contrary, Labour continued to support throughout its 13 years in government. The question was only when we would join, not if. Right up until May 2010, Labour continued to fund a specialist treasury department whose purpose was to prepare the country for entry. It was finally disbanded in George Osborne's first budget..
Is it any wonder people do not trust politicians?
Sunday, 27 May 2012
Global leadership needed..
As well as brushing aside the economic objections (to European Monetary Union), he simply ignored or dismissed without argument the political consequences of joining a single currency, and would not admit that a currency union would require a political union as well, to control tax and expenditure. Whether this was from intellectual laziness or political prejudice, I could not tell writes David Heathcoat-Amory in his memoirs. The date was May 16, 1996. He was speaking to his boss, an arch-euro supporter and at that time Chancellor of the Exchequer, Ken Clarke, to tell him why he was quitting.
In an excellent piece, Dominic Lawson explains how our political class - New Labour, the Liberal Democrats, the pre-Thatcher Conservatives and others of like opinions - knew the critics were right that EMU would inevitably demand the creation of a European government, but that because the people of Europe would not allow their politicians to discard their national sovereignty, they needed to impose it on the people by a process of stealth and denial - until it was so deeply embedded as to be unstoppable in its momentum and could be admitted and finally implemented.
As Amory explains, Thus, the countries which voted no to the treaties of Maastricht (1992), Nice (2001), the European constitution (2005) and Lisbon (2008) were ignored or told to try again. This contempt for public opinion comes at a price. It has created an EU which is all-powerful in legal terms but politically stunted, lacking authority or respect. When the EU has to do something difficult or controversial, such as rescue its currency, it can call on no loyalty or allegiance.
Now the people of Europe can clearly see that democratic deficit. In Greece, anger has spilled onto the streets. The road has run out. Yet still the European political class continues driving full-tilt, foot on the pedal, into a brick wall says Boris Johnson in a recent piece. Europe now has the lowest growth of any region in the world. We have already wasted years in trying to control this sickness in the euro, and we are saving the cancer and killing the patient. We have blighted countless lives and lost countless jobs by kidding ourselves that the answer to the crisis might be “more Europe”. And all for what? To salvage the prestige of the European Project, and to spare the egos of those who were wrong and muddle-headed enough to campaign for the euro.
It becomes more apparent by the day that Europe cannot - or simply will not - see the wood for the trees. At some point a more global perspective that understands the terrible destruction to wealth, nationhood and social cohesion which the European Project has wrought, will need to be put forward. Someone will have to hold a mirror up for European politicians to recognise just how disastrous the European Project has become. Someone must tell truth to power, and that time is not long away.
Cameron, who claims to have formed a Coalition in the national interest, should now be looking to initiate a global plan with the help of President Obama and other similarly minded world leaders outside the euro zone, to start telling Europe that the euro is no longer viable.
At the very least, if the individual countries of southern Europe are not to reintroduce drachma, escudo, paseta and lira, we need a southern European euro-currency to split from a harder, northern European euro-mark currency valued at a level that is appropriate for those economies. But that is just the first stage.
The problem that has never been properly addressed since the financial crisis first struck in 2007, has been debt. Massive corporate debt that has destroyed the balance sheets of global banks throughout the US, Britain and Europe. Sovereign debts in Europe are but a further symptom of this mess. In conjunction with the re-alignment of European currencies, we also need the greatest global write-down of corporate debt in our history.
Like a latter-day Marshall plan, we need a vision whereby the western nations write-down the destructive debts of their bankers - which will also involve the write-off of a substantial proportion of our national wealth - in return for clean balance sheets and a viable economic future that can be financed by credit worthy and properly functioning banks. And this time, conditions will be attached.
This will likely involve the destruction of both shareholders and bond holders who currently own our banks and with them a good part of our investment, pensions and insurance industry. Their plight, will need to be addressed at a later date, lest poverty become a prevailing condition of our ageing population. But in the short-term, the western economy relies on the ability of capital to finance economic activity. A pre-condition of that is the availability of capital and that is what we need to secure.
So far in this economic crisis, no government of whatever political persuasion - left, right or centre - has managed to get re-elected, despite many of them being the victims and not the architects of the financial crisis. A point of which Obama and Cameron must be acutely aware. The reason is that since Gordon Brown bailed out the banks by socialising the debt (and without any conditions being attached), all governments have followed suit and dealt only with the symptoms. Effectively, we have kicked the can down the road and not addressed the underlying cause. I may be wrong, but it seems to me that a politician who at least attempted to lead the world towards a comprehensive and lasting solution to this economic crisis, just might get the credit.
In an excellent piece, Dominic Lawson explains how our political class - New Labour, the Liberal Democrats, the pre-Thatcher Conservatives and others of like opinions - knew the critics were right that EMU would inevitably demand the creation of a European government, but that because the people of Europe would not allow their politicians to discard their national sovereignty, they needed to impose it on the people by a process of stealth and denial - until it was so deeply embedded as to be unstoppable in its momentum and could be admitted and finally implemented.
As Amory explains, Thus, the countries which voted no to the treaties of Maastricht (1992), Nice (2001), the European constitution (2005) and Lisbon (2008) were ignored or told to try again. This contempt for public opinion comes at a price. It has created an EU which is all-powerful in legal terms but politically stunted, lacking authority or respect. When the EU has to do something difficult or controversial, such as rescue its currency, it can call on no loyalty or allegiance.
Now the people of Europe can clearly see that democratic deficit. In Greece, anger has spilled onto the streets. The road has run out. Yet still the European political class continues driving full-tilt, foot on the pedal, into a brick wall says Boris Johnson in a recent piece. Europe now has the lowest growth of any region in the world. We have already wasted years in trying to control this sickness in the euro, and we are saving the cancer and killing the patient. We have blighted countless lives and lost countless jobs by kidding ourselves that the answer to the crisis might be “more Europe”. And all for what? To salvage the prestige of the European Project, and to spare the egos of those who were wrong and muddle-headed enough to campaign for the euro.
It becomes more apparent by the day that Europe cannot - or simply will not - see the wood for the trees. At some point a more global perspective that understands the terrible destruction to wealth, nationhood and social cohesion which the European Project has wrought, will need to be put forward. Someone will have to hold a mirror up for European politicians to recognise just how disastrous the European Project has become. Someone must tell truth to power, and that time is not long away.
Cameron, who claims to have formed a Coalition in the national interest, should now be looking to initiate a global plan with the help of President Obama and other similarly minded world leaders outside the euro zone, to start telling Europe that the euro is no longer viable.
At the very least, if the individual countries of southern Europe are not to reintroduce drachma, escudo, paseta and lira, we need a southern European euro-currency to split from a harder, northern European euro-mark currency valued at a level that is appropriate for those economies. But that is just the first stage.
The problem that has never been properly addressed since the financial crisis first struck in 2007, has been debt. Massive corporate debt that has destroyed the balance sheets of global banks throughout the US, Britain and Europe. Sovereign debts in Europe are but a further symptom of this mess. In conjunction with the re-alignment of European currencies, we also need the greatest global write-down of corporate debt in our history.
Like a latter-day Marshall plan, we need a vision whereby the western nations write-down the destructive debts of their bankers - which will also involve the write-off of a substantial proportion of our national wealth - in return for clean balance sheets and a viable economic future that can be financed by credit worthy and properly functioning banks. And this time, conditions will be attached.
This will likely involve the destruction of both shareholders and bond holders who currently own our banks and with them a good part of our investment, pensions and insurance industry. Their plight, will need to be addressed at a later date, lest poverty become a prevailing condition of our ageing population. But in the short-term, the western economy relies on the ability of capital to finance economic activity. A pre-condition of that is the availability of capital and that is what we need to secure.
So far in this economic crisis, no government of whatever political persuasion - left, right or centre - has managed to get re-elected, despite many of them being the victims and not the architects of the financial crisis. A point of which Obama and Cameron must be acutely aware. The reason is that since Gordon Brown bailed out the banks by socialising the debt (and without any conditions being attached), all governments have followed suit and dealt only with the symptoms. Effectively, we have kicked the can down the road and not addressed the underlying cause. I may be wrong, but it seems to me that a politician who at least attempted to lead the world towards a comprehensive and lasting solution to this economic crisis, just might get the credit.
Thursday, 24 May 2012
Middle class medals..
It's all about the money, says Fraser Nelson in this week's Spectator about winning Olympic gold medals. And all countries use public funds to increase their medal tally.
Here in the UK a staggering £27 million has been spent on rowing and £23 million on sailing over the past four years to try and retain the medals won in these events at the last games in Beijing.
Naturally you might think, the DCMS should targeted specialist sports we've been successful at in the past. But the end result of course, is that the bulk of funding is going to those sports that are disproportionately enjoyed by the already priviledged and wealthy middle class.
And I thought it was all about social mobility..
Here in the UK a staggering £27 million has been spent on rowing and £23 million on sailing over the past four years to try and retain the medals won in these events at the last games in Beijing.
Naturally you might think, the DCMS should targeted specialist sports we've been successful at in the past. But the end result of course, is that the bulk of funding is going to those sports that are disproportionately enjoyed by the already priviledged and wealthy middle class.
And I thought it was all about social mobility..
Fracking produces dramatic drop in CO2 emissions..
In a blog via Bishop Hill, the FT is reporting a dramatic drop in US carbon dioxide emissions, apparently because of the increasing use of natural gas in its economy.
The shale gas boom in the US has led to a big drop in its carbon emissions, as power generators switch from coal to cheap gas.According to the International Energy Agency, US energy-related emissions of carbon dioxide, the main greenhouse gas, fell by 450m tonnes over the past five years – the largest drop among all countries surveyed.
The evidence that shale gas will help ease the worries of those who fret about global warming now seems overwhelming. I think this is where we find out how many of them are serious about global warming and how many of them are just anti-capitalists..
Wednesday, 23 May 2012
Women deserve better..
As last week's Rochdale child abuse scandal begins to fade, how desperately sad to see on our TV screens each night, a muslim man - trailed 'respectfully' by his wife in full traditional dress - being accused of murdering his own daughter in what has become known as an 'honour killing'. The name implying that such an act is in some way acceptable. I cannot pre-judge the outcome of this trial, but it seems to me that both these offences directly reflect a deeply held cultural view of women that is both denigrating and dangerous. It says that women's lives are inferior, unimportant and worth less. Like forced marriages and female genital mutilation, it has to stop.
Muttering idiot..
Jonathan Jones blogs that Ed Balls has got Obama's spending plans completely wrong. The shadow Chancellor says that George Osborne should look to the US President for inspiration, but it seems he already is. UK government spending has fallen by an almost identical 0.9 per cent in real terms from 2010/11 to 2011/12. And it’s projected to fall a further 0.5 per cent in 2012/13, compared to Obama’s 2.6 per cent. So if Balls thinks Osborne should be more like Obama, he’s really advocating faster spending cuts. But I'm sure someone's been warning against going too far, too fast... probably some muttering idiot.
Monday, 21 May 2012
Senior moment..
Sir, last weekend the drive up to London was improved by listening to a Sherlock Holmes audiobook on the car's CD player. I was amused by my inability to follow the plot as closely as I would have liked, and put this down to middle age. It was only when I arrived at my destination that I realised the CD player was on 'shuffle' mode..
Letter in today's Telegraph
Letter in today's Telegraph
Its about people, not money..
Two great pieces on the euro: Boris Johnson in today's Telegraph and Janet Daley in the Sunday version are well worth reading, as the fate of Greek membership is now in the hands of the Greek people, who go to the polls on 17th June. Meanwhile, the EU will continue to bully and cajole them into giving the answer they want..
But one inescapable truth will continue throughout the coming disaster - and as Iain Martin writes, we should be under no illusions that whatever transpires will be a disaster - no matter what is imposed upon or rejected by the Greek people, it is only money. The Greek people and their country will survive. And the sun will continue to shine upon the beautiful Mediterranean nation that gave us the greatest civilisation of the ancient world. Only after writing off all its international debts - most of which are owed to northern European banks which Merkel and Sarkozy so desperately tried to protect - and becoming a pariah state in financial terms, whilst reverting to a devalued drachma, will the people of Greece begin the long process of rebuilding an economy destroyed by the euro.
Almost immediately those shops, hotels, restaurants, bars and cafes will become the cheapest destinations - and some of the most beautiful - in Europe. Albeit at a lower level of revenue than under the euro, the people of Greece will once again find tourists returning and with them a demand not seen in the last five years of recession and austerity. As Ambrose Evans-Pritchard writes, it is possible – perhaps likely – that Greece would be growing briskly again within 18 months, led by a tourist boom and by import substitution as local manufacturing rebounds. Then employment, national pride and a viable economic future will return.
But one inescapable truth will continue throughout the coming disaster - and as Iain Martin writes, we should be under no illusions that whatever transpires will be a disaster - no matter what is imposed upon or rejected by the Greek people, it is only money. The Greek people and their country will survive. And the sun will continue to shine upon the beautiful Mediterranean nation that gave us the greatest civilisation of the ancient world. Only after writing off all its international debts - most of which are owed to northern European banks which Merkel and Sarkozy so desperately tried to protect - and becoming a pariah state in financial terms, whilst reverting to a devalued drachma, will the people of Greece begin the long process of rebuilding an economy destroyed by the euro.
Almost immediately those shops, hotels, restaurants, bars and cafes will become the cheapest destinations - and some of the most beautiful - in Europe. Albeit at a lower level of revenue than under the euro, the people of Greece will once again find tourists returning and with them a demand not seen in the last five years of recession and austerity. As Ambrose Evans-Pritchard writes, it is possible – perhaps likely – that Greece would be growing briskly again within 18 months, led by a tourist boom and by import substitution as local manufacturing rebounds. Then employment, national pride and a viable economic future will return.
Same old Labour..
The debate has been too narrowly focussed. We should reject the snobbery that assumes the only route to social mobility runs through university - as if there is only one pathway to success writes Ed Miliband in a speech on social mobility at the Royal Society today.
Then why did Labour spend thirteen years dumbing down exams through grade inflation and opening up thousands of less academic courses from hairdressing to golf course management, in an effort to make sure that 40% of young people went to universities?
No wonder decent people mis-trust our political class. A simple apology would have been appropriate.
Then why did Labour spend thirteen years dumbing down exams through grade inflation and opening up thousands of less academic courses from hairdressing to golf course management, in an effort to make sure that 40% of young people went to universities?
No wonder decent people mis-trust our political class. A simple apology would have been appropriate.
Sunday, 20 May 2012
The euro will be the Germans' downfall..
The Greeks are against austerity but wish to remain in the euro - a logical impossibility. The Germans fail to comprehend that the euro is, and always was, a stillborn currency that will turn the eurozone into a financial wasteland. An economic dynamic is a function of competition - not only between enterprises but also between countries - that can be achieved only if states have national currencies and financial sovereignty that leave them free to set their own interest and exchange rates.
For countries that are already in trouble this is the only path to recovery - there is no alternative. As Dominic Lawson says, the burdens of propping up the euro will have to be borne by Germany, and this - along with the economically paralysing effects of the euro - will ultimately bring that nation to its knees..
Werner Keller in the Sunday Times
For countries that are already in trouble this is the only path to recovery - there is no alternative. As Dominic Lawson says, the burdens of propping up the euro will have to be borne by Germany, and this - along with the economically paralysing effects of the euro - will ultimately bring that nation to its knees..
Werner Keller in the Sunday Times
Austerity? What austerity?
I have never understood Labour's economic criticism of the Coalition. They apparently cut 'too far, too fast' causing the economy to fall into double-dip recession. But they are also now committed to borrow an additional £150bn more than their original forecasts because - apparently - they didn't borrow enough in the first place. Shouldn't Labour be pleased the government is now borrowing more than they were intending under Alastair Darling's original plan? Indeed, given that borrowing now exceeds Labour's plan, it is they and not the Coalition who should be criticised for cutting too far too fast.. this dis-ingenuous argument will go on and on.
The truth is that after two years of so-called austerity and what the left have disgustingly described as 'the Tories final solution' (Polly Toynbee), state spending has been cut by just £8bn - around 1% of GDP according to budget figures. You could not have had a more compassionate and understanding government correcting the monstrous levels of public spending than that.
The truth is that after two years of so-called austerity and what the left have disgustingly described as 'the Tories final solution' (Polly Toynbee), state spending has been cut by just £8bn - around 1% of GDP according to budget figures. You could not have had a more compassionate and understanding government correcting the monstrous levels of public spending than that.
Champions of Europe..
Congratulations to Chelsea on becoming European champions last night. A magical performance full of grit and determination. They didn't look the better team on the night, and the statistics speak for themselves - 16 corners to Bayern against just one for Chelsea. What made them champions was the unbelievable defence they put up against the might of Munich. Wave after wave of attacks tackled, stopped, blocked and repulsed in one of the most plucky performances of the year. And when it finally came to penalties, Drogba delivered. Wonderful.
Thursday, 17 May 2012
The economic future of a generation is being sacrificed by the Euro..
A rigid system that locks down each state's monetary flexibility yet limits fiscal transfers between them can only resolve its internal imbalances through painful adjustment says Cameron in today's speech about the Euro. Labour then criticise him for being patronising and arrogant.
No doubt Labour continue to believe we should be a part of this disastrous economic experiment.
The truth is that on the very night that Coalition talks were taking place in May 2010, the then out-going Chancellor Alistair Darling, phoned George Osborne from a European Finance Minister's meeting to ask if the incoming government would support a bailout for Greece, whose credit had come to an end.
Nothing since has changed. Fully two years on, the same questions are being asked, the same inappropriate solutions being offered. Cameron has been remarkably restrained over that time in commenting on the Eurozone's congenital problems. Nor did we hear from Labour any warnings as to its inherent and flawed contradictions.
Meanwhile the jobs, savings and economic future of a generation of Europeans right across the continent is being sacrificed in the name of a failed economic experiment called the Euro.
No doubt Labour continue to believe we should be a part of this disastrous economic experiment.
The truth is that on the very night that Coalition talks were taking place in May 2010, the then out-going Chancellor Alistair Darling, phoned George Osborne from a European Finance Minister's meeting to ask if the incoming government would support a bailout for Greece, whose credit had come to an end.
Nothing since has changed. Fully two years on, the same questions are being asked, the same inappropriate solutions being offered. Cameron has been remarkably restrained over that time in commenting on the Eurozone's congenital problems. Nor did we hear from Labour any warnings as to its inherent and flawed contradictions.
Meanwhile the jobs, savings and economic future of a generation of Europeans right across the continent is being sacrificed in the name of a failed economic experiment called the Euro.
Sunday, 13 May 2012
Thursday, 10 May 2012
The Alternative Queen's speech..
There is a simple technical term for why the Tory party is in its current mess. It’s called.. the 50p tax cut. Look at any graph of the opinion polls and they tell the true story. Up until March the red and blue lines indicating Labour and Tory support bump along broadly in parallel. And after March the blue line falls off a cliff.
It has nothing to do with gay pasties, marriage in a jerry can or Jeremy Hunt sending dodgy emails to Rebekah Brooks's horse. It’s because at a time when the nation was being told – and broadly accepting – that we all had to be in this together, the Chancellor suddenly leaped up and said “Actually forget all that, we’re looking after the toffs; you serfs can go hang.” writes Dan Hodges.
He is of course quite right, and the Conservatives, having lost that trust which took so long to build, will now spend the next three years trying to regain it. How careless. How stupid. How depressingly easy.
So today's queen's speech becomes an important test, not just of the government's competence, but their ability to rebuild that trust with the British electorate. Here then is the alternative program - not from what the Prime Minister has described as the 'noisy ideology' of Conservative Home and the party's right - but from the people who continue to support a Coalition of the willing - a program building upon this government's radical reforms in education, welfare and health, as well as the unfinished strategy to tackle the monstrous economic problems left by Labour.
These measures are aimed fairly at the people, whether in government through Lords reform, or as part of a continuing social revolution aimed at achieving a nation which John Major once described as being 'at ease with itself'.
Firstly a bill which decriminalises, through licensing, the supply of prostitution throughout the UK. No more pimps. No more black economy. No more exploitation. No more abuse. No more murders. Just clean, professionally run brothels, properly licensed by local authorities and contributing to the British economy - a win for the treasury, sex workers and their customers.
Secondly, a bill which decriminalises, through licensing, the supply of heroin throughout the UK. Any heroin addict may register through a GP to be a licensed user and receive clean, clinically measured and unadulterated free supplies daily. No more deaths from overdose, impurities or neglect. A health service that knows each and every addict and is able to offer support, rehabilitation and hope. And most importantly, an end to the desperate daily crimes of burglary, mugging and other theft to line the pockets of illegal and exploitative suppliers.
Thirdly, a bill which transforms prisons into adult educational facilities. We need to ensure that all prisoners are given the opportunity of learning a trade before returning to society, as well as the gift of basic literacy and numeracy guaranteed to any able prisoner with a sentence of two or more years. It is absolutely essential that every prisoner is able to become part of, and contribute towards being a worthwhile member of society.
Fourthly - and right at the heart of an alternative Queen's speech - a bill to reform the House of Lords. But not by extending a further tier of government to our already failing political class. This bill will put ordinary people at the heart of government. We propose to supply 600 citizens to serve in two week periods as members of the House of Lords. There they will vote on proposed legislation from the House of Commons. They will be chosen from the electoral register - in the same way that jurors are selected - one from each constituency, directly reflecting by gender, age, ethnicity and geography every part of our diverse national character.
David Cameron needs to put people first. Not politicians, higher rate taxpayers or special interests. He should be improving the lives of ordinary people.
It has nothing to do with gay pasties, marriage in a jerry can or Jeremy Hunt sending dodgy emails to Rebekah Brooks's horse. It’s because at a time when the nation was being told – and broadly accepting – that we all had to be in this together, the Chancellor suddenly leaped up and said “Actually forget all that, we’re looking after the toffs; you serfs can go hang.” writes Dan Hodges.
He is of course quite right, and the Conservatives, having lost that trust which took so long to build, will now spend the next three years trying to regain it. How careless. How stupid. How depressingly easy.
So today's queen's speech becomes an important test, not just of the government's competence, but their ability to rebuild that trust with the British electorate. Here then is the alternative program - not from what the Prime Minister has described as the 'noisy ideology' of Conservative Home and the party's right - but from the people who continue to support a Coalition of the willing - a program building upon this government's radical reforms in education, welfare and health, as well as the unfinished strategy to tackle the monstrous economic problems left by Labour.
These measures are aimed fairly at the people, whether in government through Lords reform, or as part of a continuing social revolution aimed at achieving a nation which John Major once described as being 'at ease with itself'.
Firstly a bill which decriminalises, through licensing, the supply of prostitution throughout the UK. No more pimps. No more black economy. No more exploitation. No more abuse. No more murders. Just clean, professionally run brothels, properly licensed by local authorities and contributing to the British economy - a win for the treasury, sex workers and their customers.
Secondly, a bill which decriminalises, through licensing, the supply of heroin throughout the UK. Any heroin addict may register through a GP to be a licensed user and receive clean, clinically measured and unadulterated free supplies daily. No more deaths from overdose, impurities or neglect. A health service that knows each and every addict and is able to offer support, rehabilitation and hope. And most importantly, an end to the desperate daily crimes of burglary, mugging and other theft to line the pockets of illegal and exploitative suppliers.
Thirdly, a bill which transforms prisons into adult educational facilities. We need to ensure that all prisoners are given the opportunity of learning a trade before returning to society, as well as the gift of basic literacy and numeracy guaranteed to any able prisoner with a sentence of two or more years. It is absolutely essential that every prisoner is able to become part of, and contribute towards being a worthwhile member of society.
Fourthly - and right at the heart of an alternative Queen's speech - a bill to reform the House of Lords. But not by extending a further tier of government to our already failing political class. This bill will put ordinary people at the heart of government. We propose to supply 600 citizens to serve in two week periods as members of the House of Lords. There they will vote on proposed legislation from the House of Commons. They will be chosen from the electoral register - in the same way that jurors are selected - one from each constituency, directly reflecting by gender, age, ethnicity and geography every part of our diverse national character.
David Cameron needs to put people first. Not politicians, higher rate taxpayers or special interests. He should be improving the lives of ordinary people.
Thursday, 3 May 2012
David Aaronovich on the left's hatred for Murdoch..
Those of us who work for The Times know that such exaggeration comes close to outright falsehood. I understand perfectly how this sounds, but I’ll say it anyway: this newspaper is the best run and most collegiate of any media organisation that I’ve worked for, and I’ve worked for a few. Mr Murdoch, therefore, is eminently fit enough to run us. As for TV, Uncle Rupert, as none of us call him, bought a loss-making satellite operation in the 1980s and, against the background of derision and opposition, turned it into BSkyB. He believed in it, invested in it, made the losses and came through. Is he fit to run it? The question is almost ludicrous.
Rupert Murdoch didn’t and doesn’t actually change big policies. Tony Blair — a convinced European — was not swayed by News International’s Europhobe inclinations. And credit, if any is due, for not joining the euro more properly lies with Gordon Brown than with any Sun editor.
Despite that, I myself have no quarrel with the long march of accountability through the various corridors of power, however uncomfortable. I welcome it. But I would prefer it to be led by people who are not associated, as Tom Watson is, with attempting the “rehabilitation of old-style trade union fixing and activist stitch-ups”, as Tony Blair said in his memoirs. Such politics was all, said Mr Blair, “great fun for those who like that of thing”. But the thing is, most of us don’t.
David Aaronovich in the Times. Spot on..
Rupert Murdoch didn’t and doesn’t actually change big policies. Tony Blair — a convinced European — was not swayed by News International’s Europhobe inclinations. And credit, if any is due, for not joining the euro more properly lies with Gordon Brown than with any Sun editor.
Despite that, I myself have no quarrel with the long march of accountability through the various corridors of power, however uncomfortable. I welcome it. But I would prefer it to be led by people who are not associated, as Tom Watson is, with attempting the “rehabilitation of old-style trade union fixing and activist stitch-ups”, as Tony Blair said in his memoirs. Such politics was all, said Mr Blair, “great fun for those who like that of thing”. But the thing is, most of us don’t.
David Aaronovich in the Times. Spot on..
Saturday, 28 April 2012
Rights and wrongs..
We've seen the argument before: because Cameron was not right wing enough, he failed to achieve a majority in 2010. Patrick O'Flynn repeats it in today's Express. What they don't tell you is that he achieved the largest swing to the Conservatives since 1931.
Indeed if more right-wing measures were needed to improve the party's polling position, why is it that a reduction in the top rate of tax for all those suffering on over £150,000 per year has resulted in the first real drop in support for the Conservatives since they took over in 2010?
Indeed if more right-wing measures were needed to improve the party's polling position, why is it that a reduction in the top rate of tax for all those suffering on over £150,000 per year has resulted in the first real drop in support for the Conservatives since they took over in 2010?
Friday, 27 April 2012
Murdoch is deceiving Leveson..
Rupert Murdoch's contribution to both the British press and, through Sky, the wider broadcasting media has been incalculable.
Indeed the UK enjoys one of the most independent and yet vociferous media in the world, substantially as a result of Murdoch's work.
But it is inconceivable that a man, so deeply involved in the production of stories over the last five decades did not know how such stories were being generated.
On the stand at Leveson this week Rupert Murdoch has not been telling the whole truth.
Indeed the UK enjoys one of the most independent and yet vociferous media in the world, substantially as a result of Murdoch's work.
But it is inconceivable that a man, so deeply involved in the production of stories over the last five decades did not know how such stories were being generated.
On the stand at Leveson this week Rupert Murdoch has not been telling the whole truth.
Wednesday, 18 April 2012
PMQ's is pure theatre..
Iain Martin berates Cameron for a feisty performance at PMQ's telling him to calm down - he could not be more wrong. This is the greatest piece of political theatre in the world - although I'm told the Australian version is even more gauche.
Knowing that Ed Miliband had several open goals with which to score today, Cameron was at his most combative. And what a sight to behold - pithy, succinct and devastating. Miliband never had a chance, resorting as ever to the whiny 'I'm suppose to ask the questions' routine which sounded truly pathetic.
Miliband should learn; this is what real Prime Ministers are made of.
Knowing that Ed Miliband had several open goals with which to score today, Cameron was at his most combative. And what a sight to behold - pithy, succinct and devastating. Miliband never had a chance, resorting as ever to the whiny 'I'm suppose to ask the questions' routine which sounded truly pathetic.
Miliband should learn; this is what real Prime Ministers are made of.
Tuesday, 17 April 2012
Hypothecating charity..
Such a good blog from Dan Hodges on the capping of charitable donations that can be off-set against tax by higher rate taxpayers, which follows on from Polly Toynbee's piece in this mornings Guardian. And just how many times have you heard me say I agree with Polly? the truth is, I can't remember the last time. Still, however misguided these two commentators are politically, they are dead right on this one. Everyone should pay their full due in taxes. Charitable donations come after tax, not before..
Thursday, 12 April 2012
Hodges on Livingston..
Dan Hodges, a Labour supporter, blogging about Ken Livingston: Maybe I am being indulgent. Perhaps we all are, those of us who are finally turning round and saying “sorry Ken, enough is enough.”
But on balance I don’t think so. I think the truly indulgent people are those who cry at their own campaign videos. Who take to the streets against Labour candidates when it suits them, and then demand loyalty from others when it doesn’t. Who use a political party as a vehicle for their own political ambitions, then abandon it when they realise it isn’t going to get them where they want to go.
Ken Livingstone has been indulged and indulged and indulged. Next month the indulgence will finally stop. The voters of London will see to that. Ouch.
But on balance I don’t think so. I think the truly indulgent people are those who cry at their own campaign videos. Who take to the streets against Labour candidates when it suits them, and then demand loyalty from others when it doesn’t. Who use a political party as a vehicle for their own political ambitions, then abandon it when they realise it isn’t going to get them where they want to go.
Ken Livingstone has been indulged and indulged and indulged. Next month the indulgence will finally stop. The voters of London will see to that. Ouch.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)















